Key Highlights
● Revenue was little changed while Net Income rose steeply
● Lower operating expenses drove the profit increase
● Marketplace Revenue grew and traffic recovered sequentially
● Full-year guidance was reaffirmed
Cars.com Inc. (NYSE:CARS), an online marketplace operating in automobile retail technology rather than a maker of vehicles or parts, reported third-quarter results with revenue roughly flat against the prior-year period and net income more than double the level of a year earlier. The Chicago company reaffirmed full-year guidance and pointed to steady progress at its core Marketplace.
Chief Executive Officer Tobias Hartmann said the quarter reinforced the growing strength of the core Marketplace. He tied the outcome to fundamental improvements made to the operating model during the year, adding: “Though still early, these steps point in the right direction.”
Under the steady revenue line, the businesses moved differently. Marketplace revenue climbed by a mid-single-digit percentage from the prior year, but declines in media and solutions products absorbed much of that gain. Total operating expenses dropped, and that decline carried through to the bottom line. Net income grew by more than double, while adjusted net income rose at a more modest pace.
Against the Street's Numbers
According to market data, revenue finished slightly under the consensus estimate, while adjusted Earnings Per Share and adjusted EBITDA each exceeded forecasts. The firm reported that the shares were flat immediately after the results were a muted response that fits the split between a small revenue shortfall and stronger profit.
The company also measured the quarter against its own forecasts. In August it projected third-quarter revenue flat to slightly higher and gave a range for adjusted EBITDA margin. The actual revenue change sat at the bottom of that revenue outlook, in effect flat, while the adjusted EBITDA Margin exceeded the top of the guided range. Cost discipline, in other words, did more to deliver the quarter's upside than sales did.
Market data longer-term data adds perspective. It described the company's revenue growth over recent years as modest and below its benchmarks, with dealer customers and revenue per customer roughly flat on a longer view. It also said brokerage estimates point to low-single-digit revenue growth over the coming year, similar to the longer-term trend.
Where the Cost Savings Came From
Total operating expenses fell by a mid-single-digit percentage, with adjusted operating expenses also declining. The second-quarter release referred to cost-reduction activities carried out in April, which had produced only a partial quarter of savings at that stage. The third quarter therefore provides a fuller view of that work.
Reported net income grew much faster than adjusted net income, which suggests that the sharp increase owes something to items excluded from the adjusted measure and to the low prior-year base. A careful reading therefore relies on both figures. Adjusted net income rose at a mid-single-digit rate, and adjusted EBITDA rose modestly, with its margin expanding from the prior-year period.
Adjusted earnings per share grew considerably faster than adjusted net income. The arithmetic points to a smaller share count, which is consistent with the company's repurchases. Operating Margin also improved substantially, according to market data, moving from the prior-year level to a figure well into the double digits.
Dealers: Fewer Customers, More Revenue Each
Dealer revenue, the largest source of sales, rose slightly from a year earlier, even though media and solutions products declined. The company's customer count edged down from both the prior quarter and the prior year, while average revenue per dealer rose on both comparisons and reached what the company described as its second-highest quarterly level on record.
Rising monthly revenue per dealer can offset a slight fall in customers, and the release suggests that product packaging is one reason. Premium+ adoption reached a higher share of the quarter's Marketplace customers, a development Hartmann described as “another milestone.” The second-quarter release also noted that Marketplace dealer customers had grown from the prior year, which indicates that the shrinkage in the overall count lies outside that core product.
OEM and National revenue, which reflects Advertising from manufacturers and large brands, declined from the prior year but rose by a double-digit percentage from the previous quarter as OEM advertising recovered. In August, the company had warned of continued pressure in this category, so the sequential recovery offers some encouragement, though the year-over-year comparison remained negative.
Tracking the Year's Operating Metrics
The recent run of operating metrics gives a clearer sense of direction than any single quarter. The dealer customer count has slipped sequentially at each recent reporting date: the first-quarter figure was higher than the second-quarter one, which was in turn higher than the latest. The decline in each step has been small, but the direction has been consistent. Average revenue per dealer, by contrast, has risen in each of the latest comparisons, up from both the previous quarter and the same quarter last year in both the second and third quarters.
Margins have followed a similar pattern against guidance. Adjusted EBITDA margin came in above the guided range in the second quarter, when management cited a partial quarter of savings from cost reduction, and it did so again in the third quarter by a wider margin relative to the range. Revenue, meanwhile, has generally been reported as in line with or modestly below expectations, so results to date reflect cost execution and revenue per dealer more than a sales acceleration.
Full-year guidance has stayed the same through both of those reports, for revenue and for adjusted EBITDA margin. Since the third-quarter margin finished above the full-year range, while the year-to-date revenue total is only slightly higher than in the prior-year period, the unchanged guidance leaves some cushion on margin for the closing months.
A Self-Service Door for Independents
One of the more strategically interesting items is Marketplace Starter, described by Hartmann as the company's “first ever self-service subscription designed to meet the needs of local independent dealers.” The company said an early group of independent dealers adopted the package. It is a non-paid subscription and is excluded from the company's Dealer Customers metric.
Because the package carries no fee, it adds no direct revenue. Any value would lie in widening the funnel, if those dealers later move to paid products. The release does not provide conversion data, so such a benefit remains prospective.
Market data October forecast, as reported, put retail used-vehicle sales at a substantial level for the year, while noting pressure from rising interest rates and consumer sentiment. That context offers a view of the wider used-vehicle market in which many such dealers operate.
Traffic Rebounds From a Deliberate Dip
Audience metrics looked better sequentially than they did year over year. Average monthly unique visitors and total visits both fell from the prior-year quarter, but both increased compared with the second quarter. The company attributed the performance to a more optimized audience Acquisition strategy, which it said grew lead volume.
The August release had reported far steeper declines in visitors and visits, and it attributed them to a deliberate shift toward value delivery. Management's position is that quality of traffic, measured in leads for dealers, matters more than raw volume. The third-quarter numbers show traffic moving back up while that strategy continues, though they remain below last year's level.
Cars.com has also highlighted its position in AI-driven search. It said a September analysis by Semrush found it was the most-cited automotive marketplace across major large language models. Carson, its AI shopping assistant, passed a milestone in monthly users and nearly doubled from a year earlier. These figures come from the company's release, and it is too soon to say how much they contribute financially.
New Faces in the Product Organization
The company has been changing its Leadership as well as its products. It named Mausam Bhatt as Chief Product Officer, a role meant to lead what the company calls product-led growth. The market recap of the call held a year ago identified Alex Vetter as chief executive at that time, while both this year's second-quarter and third-quarter releases name Hartmann in the role, so the current operating agenda has developed under a new chief executive.
Hartmann's statement summarizes that agenda as “product innovation, process efficiency, and organizational talent.” He said the company is “moving swiftly to extend that momentum” across the rest of the portfolio. That wording acknowledges an important limit of the current results: momentum is concentrated in Marketplace, while other products remain under pressure.
The portfolio beyond Marketplace includes offerings such as Dealer Inspire, DealerClub and AccuTrade, all named in the company's disclosures. The release's About section describes the group as combining industry reviews and shopper tools with technology, data and media services for dealers and OEMs, over a history that stretches back more than a quarter of a century.
Buybacks, Debt and Liquidity
Capital returns remain a significant use of cash. Cars.com repurchased more stock during the quarter and has now retired a substantial portion of the shares outstanding at the end of last year. It reaffirmed its target for the year and said it is on pace, with authorization remaining into early the year after next. Second-quarter buying was heavier than third-quarter buying, which leaves the remaining portion of the annual goal for the final months.
The company also repaid a modest amount of debt in the quarter and reported total Liquidity comprising cash and revolver capacity. Free Cash Flow for the year to date rose slightly from the comparable period, while Operating Cash Flow was almost unchanged. Market data also noted an improved free cash flow margin compared with the previous quarter.
With total debt large in relation to the Market Value reported by market data, the balance between repurchases and deleveraging is an important decision for the company. For now, it is doing both at a pace it describes as consistent with its plans.
A Mixed Market for Auto Retail
Outside the company, the retail environment offers mixed signals for dealer advertising. Market data October forecast called for new-vehicle sales above the level of last October, with a pace that has held up despite lower consumer sentiment. Jonathan Gregory of Cox said: “Healthy fleet sales, wealthier new-vehicle buyers and more access to Credit are all keeping this market relatively strong.”
On the used side, According to market data, the Manheim Used Vehicle Value index declined in September from both the prior year and August, with higher fuel costs and rising interest rates among the pressures. Cox's Jeremy Robb described this as “the weakest season for wholesale valuations.” Cox lowered its year-end forecast for the index, though it nudged its estimate for total used-vehicle sales upward.
For a marketplace, a stable sales pace supports dealers' willingness to pay for leads, while softer wholesale values and tighter consumers can make them more careful with budgets. The reaffirmed guidance, which calls for Marketplace growth to offset pressure in Dealer and OEM media products, suggests that management sees this balance as manageable through the end of the year.
Supply Shifts in the Used-Vehicle Channel
Market data also describes Supply changes that may influence dealers' sourcing and inventory decisions. Cox projected a large rise in off-lease wholesale volume, a smaller increase in rental Volume and a decline in dealer-sourced units. It also reported that days' supply in the wholesale market had risen from a year earlier, while certified pre-owned sales were projected to decline from last year's level.
The same report said large pickups and SUVs had seen Demand and values decline, while older and lower-priced vehicles held up better, and that the Manheim EV index rose from a year earlier even as the non-EV index fell. Cox expects further wholesale volume growth next year, and it listed interest rates, consumer sentiment and fuel costs as the risks to watch. Cars.com does not directly attribute its third-quarter results to any of these trends, but they describe the inventory environment that dealer customers are navigating as they weigh spending on marketplace listings and related products.
The Test Ahead
Full-year guidance remains unchanged, covering both revenue growth and adjusted EBITDA margin. Given the margin outcome in the third quarter, fourth-quarter profitability will be a measure of how much of the cost work persists as the company invests in product. Revenue will show whether Marketplace growth can do more than simply offset weakness elsewhere.
Hartmann's own qualifier, “though still early,” is an apt summary. Cars.com has shown that it can improve margins on flat sales, reduce its share count and steady its traffic. The harder task now is to reproduce that Marketplace momentum in the rest of the portfolio, which the chief executive has made an explicit goal, and to turn that momentum into consolidated revenue growth.






Please wait processing your request...