Key Highlights

  • Cocoa fell 2.90% to $5,027 a tonne on Wednesday.
  • ICE cocoa stocks hit a 2.5-year high of 3,815,074 bags.
  • Major Commodity indexes plan to cut cocoa weightings in 2027.
  • Hershey hedges well ahead, so relief arrives with a delay.

Cocoa futures fell toward $5,000 a tonne on Wednesday, November 18, approaching levels last seen in June. The contract dropped 2.90%, or $150, to $5,027, down about 12% over the past month and about 17% so far this year, as signs of abundant inventories mounted. For Hershey (NYSE:HSY), one of the largest chocolate makers in North America and a major cocoa buyer, lower costs can help margins over time.

Inventories and index changes

ICE cocoa stocks have steadily increased since the start of the year, reaching a 2.5-year high of 3,815,074 bags last Tuesday. Additional pressure has come from plans by major commodity indexes to reduce cocoa exposure in 2027. The S&P GSCI Index intends to cut its cocoa weighting by more than half to 0.5%, and the Bloomberg Commodity Index has also announced plans to reduce its holdings. Investors have been selling cocoa futures ahead of the Rebalancing in early 2027.

The scale of the turnaround is striking. In January 2025, ICE inventories were at a 21-year low and New York cocoa hit records above $11,000 a tonne in late 2024 and early 2025.

Weather provides medium-term support

The US Climate Prediction Center said the El Niño pattern that emerged in the equatorial Pacific last month could become one of the strongest in more than 75 years. El Niño typically brings warmer and drier conditions to West Africa, potentially stressing cocoa trees and reducing future yield. Farmers in Côte d'Ivoire also delivered far less cocoa to ports than a year earlier in early November, and early surveys of the 2026/27 crop showed below-average cherelle formation.

Listed companies with cocoa exposure

Hershey hedges its purchases well in advance, so changes in futures typically affect its results with a delay of several quarters, and it must balance any relief against pricing decisions and demand. Mondelez International, which owns Cadbury, Milka and Toblerone, is another large buyer, and cocoa is a significant cost for its chocolate business. It also hedges, so the benefit is gradual. Tootsie Roll Industries (NYSE:TR) is a smaller US confectioner whose costs are also affected by cocoa and sugar.

Demand recovery is the key question

Record prices in 2024 and early 2025 led chocolate makers to raise prices, shrink products and reformulate recipes, which cut cocoa use. A sustained recovery in grindings would absorb some of the stock build, while weak Demand would add to it.

What Will Decide Cocoa From Here

A weak West African main crop, disease or a strong El Niño would support prices. Continued inventory growth, weak grindings and a recovery in Ivorian and Ghanaian Supply would weigh on them. Investors will watch ICE inventories, port arrivals, fourth-quarter grinding data and results from Hershey and Mondelez. The crisis premium has faded further, and the West African main crop will decide whether the decline continues.