Key Highlights

  • Ethanol fell 1.24% to $1.79 a gallon.
  • Ethanol is down about 11% over the past month.
  • US gasoline stocks rose 5.2 million barrels in the latest week.
  • Lower ethanol with steady corn compresses producer margins.

US ethanol prices have drifted lower this autumn. Chicago ethanol fell 1.24% to $1.79 a gallon, down about 11% over the past month and about 8% above a year ago. The slide is a test for Green Plains (NASDAQ:GPRE), one of the larger dedicated US ethanol producers, whose Earnings depend on the spread between ethanol and co-product Revenue on one side and corn and Natural Gas costs on the other.

Strong production, weaker blending demand

The defining feature of the market this autumn has been high output. Energy Information Administration data in early November showed ethanol production at a 10-month high, while inventories drew.

Demand signals are softer. Ethanol is mainly blended into gasoline, so its fortunes follow fuel consumption. The latest EIA data showed gasoline inventories up 5.2 million barrels, the strongest weekly build since January, with stocks 3% above seasonal norms. Gasoline futures have fallen to an eight-month low. A narrower gap between ethanol and gasoline can reduce ethanol's appeal for discretionary blending above mandated levels.

Corn and gas set the costs

Corn is the dominant input. December corn is trading near $4.35 a bushel, down 2.73% on the day and relatively stable over recent weeks, which helps producers plan, but margins squeeze when ethanol falls faster than corn. Natural gas, the second-largest cost, is trading near $3.36 per million British thermal units, up 4.86% on colder forecasts. A cold winter that lifts gas prices would add to plant costs just as ethanol is subdued.

Policy and exports

Ethanol Demand is strongly influenced by the Renewable Fuel Standard and by the debate over permanent year-round sales of E15, a 15% ethanol blend. Exports to Canada, Europe and parts of Asia offer an outlet, though trade policy and currencies make that channel less predictable than domestic blending.

Listed companies with ethanol exposure

Green Plains is highly sensitive to the crush spread, and lower ethanol prices with steady corn generally compress it. REX American Resources holds interests in several ethanol plants and has similar Margin sensitivity. Archer-Daniels-Midland (NYSE:ADM) produces ethanol inside a much larger processing and trading business, so the effect is diluted. Valero Energy (NYSE:VLO) also runs one of the largest US ethanol businesses, where ethanol is both a product and a blending component.

What Will Decide Ethanol Margins

Investors will watch weekly EIA ethanol data, USDA corn reports, any Renewable Fuel Standard or E15 decisions and quarterly results from Green Plains, REX, ADM and Valero. Ethanol is entering winter with plentiful Supply and a softer gasoline backdrop, so margins will depend on how corn and fuel demand evolve.