Key Highlights

• Gallagher's Revenue rose 24.2% with organic growth of 6% combined, while Brown & Brown's revenue rose 30.4% but organic revenue fell 0.7%.

• Both firms closed transformational deals in August 2025: Gallagher acquired AssuredPartners and Brown & Brown acquired Accession Risk Management Group for about $9.83 billion.

• Gallagher spent $327 million on acquisitions and $170 million on Buybacks in the quarter, while Brown & Brown spent just $13 million on deals and $251 million on share repurchases.

Deals now drive most of the headline growth at Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. (NYSE:AJG) and Brown & Brown, Inc. (NYSE:BRO), which is why their recent acquisitions Warrant a closer look at both S&P 500 insurance brokers. Each closed a major Acquisition in August 2025, and second-quarter 2026 results showed revenue up 24% at Gallagher and 30% at Brown & Brown. The key difference is underneath: Gallagher's existing Business still grew organically by 6%, while Brown & Brown's organic revenue slipped. That gap shapes how investors might judge each company's buying spree.

Two Transformational Deals, One Year On

Brown & Brown completed its purchase of Accession Risk Management Group, parent of retail broker Risk Strategies and wholesaler One80 Intermediaries, on August 13, 2025. The seller's announcement put the price at about $9.83 billion and Accession's annual revenue at $1.7 billion.

Gallagher closed its acquisition of AssuredPartners, a US broker with offices in the UK and Ireland, on August 18, 2025. It said at the time it expected double-digit accretion to adjusted Earnings Per Share once synergies were included.

For both brokers, the next few months are a turning point. Organic revenue, the measure that strips out newly acquired operations for their first twelve months as well as disposals and currency effects, begins to include these businesses once they pass their first anniversary.

Why Brokers Keep Buying Brokers

Insurance broking is fragmented, and acquisitions are a long-standing growth route for both groups. A buyer gains new clients, producers and specialist expertise, and can often lift the acquired firm's margins by sharing systems, carrier relationships and back-office functions.

The arithmetic works when the price paid, relative to earnings, is lower than the value the market places on the buyer's own earnings, and when financing costs stay below the returns generated. Synergies widen that gap; overpaying, losing key staff or borrowing expensively narrows it.

Gallagher (NYSE:AJG): Big Deal Plus Steady Tuck-Ins

Gallagher's second-quarter release, dated July 30, 2026, reported total revenue of $4,003 million for the three months to June 30, 2026, up 24.2% from $3,222 million. Organic growth was 5% in brokerage and 12% in risk management, its claims-administration business, or 6% combined.

The group kept buying smaller firms alongside the integration. It closed six tuck-in acquisitions in the quarter, with estimated annualised revenue of $58 million, and 14 in the first half, representing about $107 million.

Management said more than 30 term sheets were signed or being prepared, representing around $500 million of annualised revenue. It targeted AssuredPartners synergies of $160 million a year by the end of 2026, rising to as much as $325 million by early 2028, and kept its 6% full-year organic growth target.

Brown & Brown (NYSE:BRO): Growth Bought, Organic Stalled

Brown & Brown's second-quarter release of July 27, 2026, showed total revenue of $1.7 billion, up 30.4% from $1,285 million. Organic revenue fell 0.7%, although including contingent commissions, which are bonuses insurers pay brokers for Volume or profitability, it grew 0.7%.

Retail grew 1.5% organically, while Specialty Distribution fell 3.5%, hurt by lower catastrophe property rates and timing of new business. Because many broker commissions are a share of the premium, falling rates reduce revenue even when clients renew.

Profit still rose. Net Income increased 24.7% to $288 million and diluted EPS rose to $0.84 from $0.78, while adjusted EPS grew 3.9% to $1.07. The first half looked similar: revenue rose 33.0% to $3.6 billion, organic revenue fell 0.3%, and adjusted EPS grew 6.0% to $2.46. Chief executive J. Powell Brown said the company had great momentum heading into the second half.

Paying for Growth: Prices, Integration and Buybacks

Acquisitions add revenue immediately but carry costs that show up in GAAP numbers. Gallagher recorded $113 million of integration costs in the second quarter, which helps explain why its GAAP diluted EPS fell even as adjusted EPS rose 23%. Both brokers also reported lower adjusted margins than a year earlier, although the releases do not isolate how much of that reflects the acquired businesses.

Deal prices are rising. Gallagher's finance chief said on the call that multiples paid rose to about 11.3 times earnings before interest, tax, Depreciation and Amortisation in the second quarter from roughly 9.4 times in the first, though he noted synergy-heavy transactions lifted the figure. He also estimated close to $10 billion of capacity for acquisitions over the next two years.

The two are now allocating Capital differently. Brown & Brown spent only $13 million on acquisitions in the second quarter but about $251 million on share repurchases. Gallagher spent $327 million on acquisitions and $170 million on buybacks in the same period.

Over the first half, Brown & Brown spent about $30 million on acquisitions and roughly $527 million on buybacks, against about $616 million and $480 million at Gallagher. On this evidence, Brown & Brown is prioritising the digestion of Accession and returning capital, while Gallagher keeps layering tuck-ins onto AssuredPartners.

What Could Undermine the Deal Story

The main risk is that acquisitions mask weaker underlying growth. If Brown & Brown's organic revenue stays flat once Accession enters the comparison, investors may question how much value the deal adds beyond scale. Softer property pricing affects both firms and could persist.

Integration and financing are further risks. Synergy targets are management estimates, and retaining acquired producers matters in a people-driven industry. Brown & Brown's interest expense roughly doubled to about $100 million, reflecting borrowing for Accession. Higher purchase multiples could make future tuck-ins less rewarding.

Signposts for the Next Quarters

Third-quarter results will show organic growth with both large deals increasingly in the base. Watch Brown & Brown's Specialty Distribution trend, Gallagher's progress towards $160 million of AssuredPartners synergies by end-2026, the rate of new tuck-ins against its roughly $500 million pipeline, and whether either company shifts the balance between deals and buybacks.