Key Highlights
• AIG's General Insurance net premiums written rose 9% to $7.5 billion with the combined ratio improving to 89.0%, while The Hartford's Business Insurance premiums grew 5%.
• Both companies' underlying combined ratios, which strip out catastrophes and reserve changes, rose modestly, signaling that pricing gains are slowing relative to claims costs.
• AIG completed the sale of its remaining Corebridge Financial stake in May 2026, while The Hartford agreed to sell Hartford Funds to Wellington Management for up to $1.9 billion.
Business insurance is now the core profit engine at American International Group, Inc. (NYSE:AIG) and The Hartford Insurance Group, Inc. (NYSE:HIG), two S&P 500 insurers whose commercial coverage lines are under close watch this year. In the three months to June 30, 2026, AIG's commercial units grew net premiums by roughly a tenth, while The Hartford's Business Insurance segment grew written premiums by 5%. Yet the quarter also showed pricing momentum cooling, so the question is less whether commercial lines matter than how long current margins can last.
Where the Commercial Money Is Made
Commercial insurance protects companies rather than households: property, general liability, workers' compensation, professional and financial lines, marine and other speciality cover. Premiums are negotiated with Brokers and agents, pricing is adjusted at each renewal, and claims on Liability lines can take years to settle.
AIG has reshaped itself around its General Insurance business after selling its remaining stake in life and retirement group Corebridge Financial on May 7, 2026, for about $710 million. It splits commercial activity between North America Commercial and International Commercial, alongside a Global Personal unit.
The Hartford, founded in 1810, is more US-centred. Its Business Insurance segment spans Small Business, Middle & Large Business and Global Specialty, and sits beside Personal Insurance and Employee Benefits. The company agreed on June 3, 2026, to sell its Hartford Funds mutual-fund arm to Wellington Management in a deal valued at up to $1.9 billion, sharpening its focus on insurance.
Reading the Quarter
AIG reported on August 6, 2026. General Insurance net premiums written rose 9% to $7.5 billion and Underwriting income increased 10% to $686 million. The combined ratio improved to 89.0%. Adjusted after-tax income per share rose 10% to $2.00, although Net Income per share fell 10% to $1.78.
The commercial units did the heavy lifting. North America Commercial net premiums grew 9% to $3.1 billion with an 84.0% combined ratio, while International Commercial grew 11%, or 10% in constant currency, to $2.6 billion. Global Personal also improved, its combined ratio falling to 92.9% from 98.5%. Catastrophe charges of $210 million cost 3.4 loss-ratio points.
The Hartford reported on July 23, 2026. Net income available to common stockholders reached $1.3 billion, or $4.68 per diluted share, lifted by $318 million of income from discontinued operations tied to the Hartford Funds sale. Core earnings, the company's measure excluding such items, edged up to $945 million. Trailing 12-month core Earnings Return on Equity improved to 18.7% from 16.0%.
Within Business Insurance, Small Business written premiums rose 7% to $1.61 billion, the fastest of the three units. Middle & Large Business reached $1.25 billion and Global Specialty $1.14 billion, both growing in low single digits.
Pricing Is Cooling, Not Collapsing
The underlying ratio strips out catastrophes and prior-year reserve changes, so it best reflects current pricing against current claims trends. On that measure, both companies slipped modestly. AIG's accident-year ratios rose in both commercial units, and International Commercial's reported combined ratio jumped to 91.3%, including $75 million of net losses related to the Middle East conflict.
The Hartford's Business Insurance underlying combined ratio rose to 89.3% from 88.0%, while its reported ratio weakened more sharply to 91.4% because prior-year reserve releases were 2.9 points less favourable. Its financial supplement shows renewal price increases in Small Business and Middle & Large Business smaller than a year earlier.
AIG's management described the market as moving from broad positive pricing into a more selective environment. The mechanism matters: when rate increases fall below claims inflation, underwriting margins compress unless insurers cut expenses, reshape their mix or grow in better-priced niches such as smaller accounts.
Balance Sheets and Capital Returns
Investment income is diverging. The Hartford's net Investment income rose to $800 million from $658 million, helped by limited partnerships and alternative investments. AIG's fell to $1.13 billion from $1.47 billion, attributed to lower income from Corebridge and equity holdings.
Both are returning capital. AIG repurchased $641 million of stock and paid $263 million of dividends. The Hartford bought back $450 million, paid $165 million of dividends and announced a new $4.2 billion repurchase authorisation running to the end of 2028.
Book values rose at both. AIG's Book Value per share reached $77.39 at June 30, against $74.14 a year earlier. The Hartford's book value per diluted share was $70.28, up 6.0% since the end of 2025.
Leadership and Portfolio Changes
AIG's Leadership has changed materially. Eric Andersen became president and chief executive on June 1, 2026, and on September 2, AIG said Peter Zaffino would step down as executive chair, with lead independent director John Rice becoming chair from September 15. The Hartford remains led by chairman and chief executive Christopher Swift.
The practical difference is geography. AIG's commercial book is heavily international, which brings Diversification but also currency effects and exposure to events such as the Middle East losses. The Hartford's business is concentrated in the US, making it more sensitive to American litigation trends and domestic small-business activity.
What Could Undermine the Case
Softer pricing is the central risk: if renewal increases keep slowing while legal and medical costs rise, underlying ratios could drift higher. Reserve releases have flattered past results; The Hartford's smaller release this quarter shows how quickly that support can fade. Geopolitical and catastrophe losses remain unpredictable, as AIG's Middle East charge showed. The Hartford also faces weaker Employee Benefits core earnings, down 15% to $139 million, and a 7% fall in Personal Insurance written premiums.
Commercial-Pricing Signals Ahead
The most useful signals will be each insurer's commercial underlying or accident-year combined ratio, renewal pricing disclosures in The Hartford's supplements, AIG's commercial net premium growth under its new leadership, the completion of the Hartford Funds sale, expected in the first quarter of 2027, and whether both firms sustain their buyback pace.






Please wait processing your request...