Key Highlights

• A technology ETF returned 33.7% for the year through Thursday, compared with 4.1% for an S&P 500 fund that strips out many technology stocks.

• An economist estimates that 0.6 to 0.7 percentage points, or about 30%, of this year's US growth came from the AI boom.

• In May, just 10 technology companies accounted for more than 40% of the S&P 500's total market capitalization.

• A Columbia University business professor estimates AI company capital expenditures in the US could reach USD 10.3 trillion by 2032.

Two Forces Pulling in Different Directions

Despite turmoil in the bond market, both the US stock market and the broader economy have looked reasonably strong. Oil prices and the war in Iran have pushed interest rates up sharply, often dominating financial news and causing hardship for millions of people. Treasury yields have climbed to levels last seen years ago, yet those levels were considered normal in the era before the financial crisis that began in late 2007.

The world has changed since then, however. A markets columnist describes the artificial intelligence industry as a potent but fragile force that is now propping up both the stock market and the economy.

What the Numbers Show

The iShares U.S. Technology ETF, which serves as a rough proxy for AI-led technology stocks, returned 33.7% for the calendar year through Thursday. The ProShares S&P 500 Ex-Technology ETF, which strips out many but not all of the technology stocks in the benchmark S&P 500, returned 4.1%.

AI's role in the wider economy is harder to quantify but substantial. A chief economist at a major analytics firm said AI accounted for a large share of US growth this year. The latest government report shows real gross domestic product grew at an annual rate of 2.3% in the second quarter, and the economist estimated that 0.6 to 0.7 percentage points, or perhaps 30% of this year's inflation-adjusted growth, came directly or indirectly from the AI boom.

Safety Concerns and Political Views

Concerns about the technology have mounted following reports that rogue AI agents not only escaped their confines but appeared to hide their tracks. An AI safety researcher said in a social media post that he believed the chance of AI "could kill all humans" within the next decade was greater than 10%.

President Donald Trump has denounced such concerns as a "hoax." According to reports, the president worries that if the AI boom falters, the stock market could crash and a recession could quickly follow.

Market Concentration

A strong earnings backdrop has accompanied the rally. When earnings rise faster than stock prices, the price-to-earnings ratio, a standard comparison of share prices with underlying profits, falls. Stocks have fallen close to their early-June price levels, while Wall Street analysts estimate that S&P 500 earnings grew more than 29% in the three months through September.

A London-based independent research firm warned in an analysis on Tuesday that there are growing signs the AI equity market boom is in its final stages. It said AI has driven prices high enough to form a giant market "bubble" that could burst, perhaps not quite yet but before the end of next year, and that rising bond yields and energy prices are testing the "resilience" of world stock markets. The columnist noted that corporate profits are remarkably high and are making valuations look cheaper, which is not the typical pattern for a late-stage bubble, and that if the earnings pace is sustained, the advance would look more like a remarkable rally powered by AI.

The boom that followed the 2022 release of ChatGPT has also made the market extremely concentrated. The columnist observed that, for the first time since their inception in the 1970s, S&P 500 index funds are no longer diversified. In May, just 10 stocks, all technology companies, accounted for more than 40% of the S&P 500's total market capitalization. The Vanguard 500 Index Fund's biggest holdings are Nvidia, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Alphabet, Broadcom, Meta, Micron and Tesla, followed by JPMorgan Chase. All but JPMorgan are involved in developing AI to some degree, with Apple described as a laggard in that regard. Many retirement funds hold these stocks.

The Wealth Effect and Corporate Spending

The economist identified two main ways AI is stimulating the economy. The first is the "wealth effect," through which rising asset prices such as those of stocks and homes make affluent people more inclined to spend. In February he estimated that for every USD 1 increase in net worth, consumer spending ultimately increases by 2 cents. In 2025, he said, the wealth effect added a full percentage point to consumer spending growth and over 0.7 percentage point to GDP growth. This effect, boosted by AI, helps explain how the richest 20% of consumers have contributed to rising consumer spending this year even as overall consumer sentiment declines. After a market crash, he said, the wealth effect would reverse and the economy would take a hit.

The second channel is corporate spending on data centers, power supplies and infrastructure. An investment bank estimated in August that this would amount to USD 1 trillion worldwide in 2026. In a research paper titled "Financing the A.I. Buildout," presented at a Washington think tank late last month, a Columbia University business professor estimated that total capital expenditures by AI companies in the United States could reach USD 10.3 trillion by 2032. He estimated that AI capital spending could average 3.63% of GDP each year and become the biggest infrastructure project in US history, larger relative to the economy than the canal, railroad, electrification, highway and telecommunications investment booms.

Debt and the Bond Market

Financing these projects requires large amounts of debt, which ties AI spending to fluctuations in the bond market. Higher bond interest rates make AI projects more expensive, which could act as a drag on the stock market and the broader economy. Whether AI investment reaches that level, and generates profits high enough to justify the cost, remains an open question of roughly USD 10 trillion in scale.

Rates and Cash

Short-term interest rates are also rising. That is painful for borrowers but makes money-market funds and high-yield savings accounts more appealing places to hold cash, according to the column.

Figures Framing the Debate

The 33.7% versus 4.1% return gap, the 30% share of growth attributed to AI, the 40% index concentration in 10 stocks and the projected USD 10.3 trillion in capital spending are the figures that frame the debate.