Key Highlights
- Ned Davis Research found that the S&P 500 rose through year-end in five of eight midterm cycles since 1930 when the president's party lost the House.
- Five of eight is 62.5%, simple arithmetic on that published count, which leaves three cycles where the index did not rise through year-end.
- Democrats were projected to win the House on November 3, 2026, so the condition in that study appears to be met, while Senate projections differed.
- Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (NYSEARCA:VOO) holds the S&P 500 stocks, so its path follows the index that the study measured.
What the History Shows
The historical claim is narrow. Ned Davis Research counted midterm cycles since 1930 in which the president's party lost the House, found eight such cases, and reported that the S&P 500 rose through year-end in five of them. The firm's count does not say how large the gains or losses were, which matters because a small rise and a large drop can both fit in a tally. A separate circulating note that stocks have not declined from November 1 of a midterm year through April since the 1930s could not be verified and is not used. Another published comment said midterms shape near-term performance but do little to long-run returns. Taken together, the history is a base rate, meaning a starting probability that investors then adjust for current conditions such as inflation, interest rates and earnings, rather than a forecast that stands on its own.
How Election Results Reach Prices
Elections move prices through expectations for taxes, spending and regulation. A divided Congress usually lowers the chance of sweeping new laws, which reduces uncertainty. Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (NYSEARCA:VOO) is a low-cost fund that holds the index stocks in proportion to market value, so it is dominated by the largest technology companies. That is why policy fears about artificial intelligence and data centers matter more to it than a tax change on a small industry. Valuation also frames the story: the forward price-to-earnings ratio was 18.7 on October 30, below the five-year average of 19.8 and the ten-year average of 19.1, according to FactSet (NYSE:FDS).
Risks and What to Watch
History is a thin guide. Eight cases is a small sample, and each period had different rates, Inflation and earnings. This year the Federal Reserve held at 3.75% to 4.00% on October 28 with two dissents favoring a hike, and markets priced roughly 84% to 85% odds of a December increase. Third-quarter S&P 500 Earnings growth was 30.2% on a blended basis as of October 30, with 82% of companies beating estimates. Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (NYSEARCA:VOO) would be hurt by a jump in the 10-year yield, which was reported near 4.89% to 4.93% on November 2 and 3, or by a stumble in AI spending. Because the fund holds the whole index, it cannot avoid sectors that fall out of favor.
Where Things Stand
It can, and the record leans that way, but it does not promise it. Five of eight cycles is better than a coin flip yet leaves three failures, and Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (NYSEARCA:VOO) faces rate and AI risks that did not exist in most earlier cases. The balance of evidence favors watching earnings, which are growing at about 30%, and the Bond Market rather than relying on the calendar. Investors who want a rule should note that the study offers none. Key dates ahead are the October jobs report on November 6 and the Fed meeting on December 8 to 9.






Please wait processing your request...