Key Highlights

  • CNN, MS NOW and Politico filed a lawsuit against President Trump seeking to reverse a total ban on the three outlets from the White House.
  • Journalists from the three outlets were barred from entering the White House two days after Trump announced the ban in a Social Media post.
  • The lawsuit alleges violations of both the Due Process Clause and the First Amendment, arguing the ban targeted the outlets based on their reporting.
  • Trump has said the ban was justified even if it is ultimately overturned by a court, citing what he described as biased coverage.

Outlets File Suit Over Access Ban

CNN, MS NOW and Politico filed a lawsuit against President Trump seeking to reverse his ban preventing journalists from the three outlets from entering the White House. Journalists from the outlets had been barred from the building two days after Trump announced the ban in a social media post accusing the outlets of writing false and misleading coverage about him.

The lawsuit, filed in US District Court in Washington, argues the ban represents a direct assault on First Amendment protections, asserting it has already severely impeded the outlets' ability to cover the administration.

Legal Arguments

The complaint alleges the ban violates the Due Process Clause of the Constitution by failing to provide advance notice or an opportunity to challenge the decision, and by failing to establish clear standards guiding the president's action. It further argues the ban violates the First Amendment by retaliating against protected newsgathering and speech, and by barring the outlets from a nonpublic forum for what the suit characterizes as unlawful reasons, including discrimination based on the outlets' perceived viewpoints.

In a joint statement, the three outlets said they had notified the government of their intent to file suit to protect their First Amendment rights and defend the principle that the government does not determine what the press reports or publishes.

Trump's Response

Trump, in a social media post following the lawsuit's announcement, said the White House was not launching an assault on the free press but rather on what he described in strong terms as corrupt and coordinated false reporting, characterizing it as a threat to national security that had to be stopped. He had not previously cited national security as a justification for the ban and offered no specific examples supporting the claim.

Additional Developments

The lawsuit cites the White House's removal of one of the outlets from its scheduled pool rotation duties as further evidence of the ban's harm. The case has been assigned to a federal judge who, in a separate case in 2018, previously ordered the restoration of a journalist's press credentials after the White House had revoked them following a contentious press exchange.

The case is being heard in the same court where the Associated Press maintains a pending lawsuit over a separate partial ban affecting its journalists' access to certain restricted White House spaces, a case in which an appeals court has blocked a lower court ruling favorable to the AP while an appeal proceeds.

Outlook

The outlets have also filed a motion seeking a temporary restraining order that would immediately restore their press credentials while the broader case proceeds, with the timeline for a ruling on that request remaining unclear.