Key Highlights

  • Historical analysis of the Dow Jones Industrial Average around elections since 1900 suggests the president's party has little consistent effect on market direction
  • Markets have generally reacted positively to unified governments, where one party controls the White House and both chambers of Congress, with the notable exception of 2008
  • Since 1980, only a small share of congressional sessions have featured unified government, making divided government the more common arrangement
  • A Republican presidency paired with a Democratic-controlled Congress has historically coincided with some of the strongest market gains in the dataset examined

Party Control Shows Limited Consistent Impact on Markets

While the two major US political parties differ significantly in their approach to fiscal policy, a review of historical election periods suggests the party controlling the White House and Congress has had little consistent impact on the direction of the stock market. The analysis compared the Dow Jones Industrial Average at the start of October, roughly one month before a November election, with its level at the end of the following March, capturing the period of electoral uncertainty through the early days of a new administration and congressional session.

Since 1900, just over half of the 62 congressional sessions examined represented unified governments, in which a single party controlled the White House, the Senate, and the House of Representatives. However, unified government has become considerably less common in recent decades, with only a handful of the congressional sessions since 1980 featuring single-party control of all three institutions.

Unified Governments Have Generally Coincided With Market Gains

Based on the historical periods examined, markets have often reacted positively to unified party control of government, with the notable exception of the 2008 to 2009 period, when the financial crisis triggered a sharp market decline despite Democratic control of the White House and Congress following that year's election. Other unified government periods, including Trump's 2024 election win and subsequent trifecta, as well as Obama's 2008 election before the financial crisis fully took hold, and Reagan-era and Clinton-era unified governments, generally saw the Dow post gains ranging from modest single-digit increases to significant double-digit growth over the measured period.

Divided Government Has Also Coincided With Market Strength

Periods of divided government, in which Congress is split between the two parties or controlled by the opposition to the president, have also frequently coincided with market gains. Markets have shown a particularly positive historical association with a Republican president paired with a Democratic-controlled Congress, a combination that has coincided with some of the largest gains examined in the historical dataset. Split Congress scenarios under both Democratic and Republican presidents have similarly tended to coincide with market gains rather than declines in most periods studied.