Key Highlights

  • The Justice Department cited a novel written by former FBI Director James Comey as evidence in urging a federal judge not to dismiss threat charges against him.
  • Prosecutors allege Comey's May 2025 Instagram post of seashells forming "86 47" constituted a coded threat against President Trump, similar to a scene in Comey's own fictional book.
  • Comey's attorneys argue "86" is common restaurant slang for removing an item from a menu and that the post was not intended as a threat.
  • The filing comes in response to a motion by Comey's lawyers seeking dismissal of the case on grounds of vindictive and selective prosecution.

Prosecutors Draw on Comey's Fiction in Court Filing

The Department of Justice cited a novel written by James Comey in a court filing urging a federal judge not to dismiss criminal charges accusing the former FBI director of threatening President Trump through a 2025 Social Media post. The filing, submitted late Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina, argues that Comey, like a character in his fictional book, used coded language to suggest violence against a political adversary.

The charges stem from a May 2025 Instagram post showing seashells arranged on a North Carolina beach forming the numbers "86 47." Prosecutors argue there is "no serious dispute" that an objective viewer could interpret the post as a threat, citing a slang dictionary defining "86" as historically meaning to kill or eliminate.

Defense Argues Post Reflected Common Slang, Not a Threat

Comey's attorneys have argued that "86" is widely used in the restaurant industry to indicate an item is no longer available, and that Trump, the 47th president, was not the intended target of any threat. His lawyers describe "86 47" as a "well-known political slogan" expressing opposition to the president rather than a call to violence. Comey's filing also noted that FBI searches of AI tools in May 2026 produced mixed results on the term's meaning, with one response noting that career law enforcement officials have disputed any violent connotation.

The filing was submitted in response to a motion from Comey's legal team seeking dismissal of the indictment on grounds of vindictive and selective prosecution. Comey has been a frequent critic of Trump, who fired him as FBI director in 2017.

Case Follows Earlier Dismissed Indictment

This is not Comey's first federal indictment. A separate case brought against him in Virginia in September 2025, related to alleged false testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee in 2020, was dismissed in November after a judge ruled the prosecutor who obtained the indictment had been unlawfully appointed. Comey has denied wrongdoing in both cases.