Key Highlights

• The European Securities and Markets Authority said in its twice-yearly risk report that prediction markets raise significant investor protection and market integrity concerns requiring continued monitoring.

• Esma said market manipulation and Insider Trading risks reach new levels on prediction markets, particularly those with limited identity verification such as Polymarket.

• The warning highlights a growing divergence between the EU's cautious stance and the more welcoming approach of US regulators toward prediction-style financial products.

• Prediction markets remain largely prohibited across much of Europe, though platforms report accessing users through VPNs and are intensifying lobbying efforts to ease restrictions.

A Sector Under Growing Regulatory Scrutiny

The European Securities and Markets Authority has warned that fast-growing prediction markets such as Polymarket and Kalshi are "rife with insider trading" and expose investors to serious risks of financial loss and exploitation by more sophisticated participants. The warning, issued in Esma's twice-yearly risk report, said the platforms raise a range of investor protection and market integrity concerns that require continued monitoring.

Prediction markets have grown increasingly popular in the United States as a way to bet on a wide range of future events, including sports outcomes, election results and Commodity prices. European regulations, however, have kept the platforms largely prohibited across much of the continent. Esma said the gamified structure of these platforms, combined with their emotional dynamics and social media-driven promotion, exposes inexperienced retail investors to significant risks of financial loss, addictive behavior and exploitation.

Insider Trading Concerns Intensify

The regulator said concerns about market manipulation and insider trading on prediction markets have reached new levels, particularly on platforms with limited identity verification such as Polymarket. "A growing number of incidents illustrates that prediction markets are rife with insider trading," Esma said in its report.

The warning follows a high-profile case in April, when a US soldier involved in the raid to capture Venezuelan leader Nicolás Maduro was charged with placing wagers on the mission using advanced knowledge of the operation, earning a substantial profit. The individual has pleaded not guilty to the charges.

A Growing Transatlantic Regulatory Divide

Esma's negative assessment stands in sharp contrast to the more welcoming approach taken by US regulators, which have approved several new financial products based on prediction-style contracts. In Europe, platforms such as Polymarket and Kalshi remain largely unauthorized, meaning their services are prohibited for consumers, though Europeans may still access them by concealing their location using a VPN. The industry has responded by intensifying its lobbying efforts to ease restrictions across the bloc.

Esma noted that Malta is exploring a regulatory framework for prediction markets, and both Polymarket and Kalshi state on their websites that they prohibit users in some, but not all, EU member states from placing orders. In the United Kingdom, the Financial Conduct Authority has said it is considering whether to reform its rules on retail access to prediction markets, despite maintaining that its existing ban on binary Options remains appropriate given their speculative, gambling-like nature.

Platforms Push for European Expansion Regardless

Polymarket said this week that it is growing its presence and expanding into Europe, announcing it had joined the Brussels-based trade association Blockchain for Europe. The company's chief legal officer, Neal Kumar, said Polymarket is committed to engaging early and openly with policymakers across the bloc. The firm operates both a crypto-based international version and a more limited US-only version regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, which opened an investigation into Polymarket earlier this year.

Kalshi, which overtook Polymarket this year to become the largest prediction market by trading volume, has also said it is working to replicate its US-regulated model overseas. Co-founder Luana Lopes Lara said in July that the company was in talks with various international regulators and was excited about the prospect of future European expansion.

A Sector at a Regulatory Crossroads

With US regulators continuing to expand the range of approved prediction-style products even as European authorities sound the alarm, the sector's next phase of growth will likely hinge on whether individual EU member states follow Malta's lead in exploring a formal regulatory framework, or whether Esma's warning prompts a more unified and cautious stance across the bloc.