Key Highlights

  • Fed officials have spoken publicly more than 40 times since the September rate hike, countering Chair Warsh’s preference for silence.
  • US consumer prices rose 3.7 percent in September from a year earlier, leaving an October rate hike a coin toss.
  • Warsh convened a task force reviewing the quarterly rate-path projections, known as the dot plot, a staple of Fed communication.
  • Warsh speaks in Bangkok on Friday at the IMF annual meeting, his final chance to shape expectations before the decision.

The Push for Silence

Federal Reserve Chair Kevin Warsh wants a quieter central bank. Colleagues who see public communication as a core part of the job are taking to television, podcasts, interviews, social media and speaker platforms to state their policy views. Nearly all of them have made appearances, more than 40 since September’s rate increase.

Their voices have had an effect. Traders have scaled back rate-hike bets that had grown after the September increase and Warsh’s own silence on how much more the Fed needs to do. Data on Wednesday showed consumer prices rose 3.7 percent in September from a year earlier, shaking up expectations again. An October hike is now seen as a coin toss, which sharpens attention on what Warsh’s silence costs in clarity.

Warsh’s Position

Warsh speaks in Bangkok on Friday at 0330 GMT, 11:30 p.m. ET Thursday, at the International Monetary Fund’s annual meeting. It is a final chance to shape expectations for a decision less than two weeks away.

In speeches at Sintra, Portugal, and Jackson Hole, Wyoming, in testimony and at press conferences, he has argued that the less policymakers say about where rates are heading, the more markets take cues from economic data, a better source of information for the Fed. He has removed hints of forward guidance from the Fed’s post-meeting statement and convened a task force reviewing the quarterly rate-path projections that have been a staple of Fed communication for years.

A fully quiet Fed marks a reversal of decades of movement away from the cryptic style of Alan Greenspan, which Warsh openly admires. This week, Robert Hall and Michael Woodford, whose research steered central banks toward franker communication about the policy path, won the 2026 Nobel Prize in economics. The quiet-Fed drive also comes as the Fed seeks to protect its accountability amid White House efforts to influence policy.

Colleagues Keep Talking

Other policymakers have said they keep speaking, in part because they think it matters for monetary policy. Beth Hammack, president of the Cleveland Fed, said in an interview on Monday that if someone presents an argument that not speaking helps households and businesses make better decisions and strengthens the institution’s credibility, she is all ears, but she called it a pretty hard argument to make.

Remarks from New York Fed President John Williams and Vice Chair Philip Jefferson were especially effective in resetting rate-hike expectations. A former Fed vice chair now at an investment firm said markets took note of two members of the leadership trio giving a consistent message. He said he saw his own role in that job as communicating the chair’s thinking, and that today it is important to listen to all committee members.

Governor Christopher Waller, in Turkey last week, said additional rate hikes are needed, not necessarily at consecutive meetings but within an acceptable period. An exact rate path, he said, keeps the Fed from adjusting to new information, a risk Warsh has also raised. Giving no signal at all, Waller said, surprises markets and creates volatility, with investors pricing a path that applies too little or too much restraint.

Williams and Jefferson spoke in recent weeks to make the case against rushing on hikes. Markets were pricing a strong conviction for a series of hikes at odds with the Fed’s September dot plot, which showed a less aggressive path.

A similar situation came in August, when markets bet heavily against a near-term hike after Warsh declined to give a detailed rationale for July’s decision to hold rates steady despite what he called a no-tolerance policy on inflation. That time Warsh himself broke the silence. While repeating his call for a quieter Fed, he said he was not convinced a recent cooling in inflation marked a clear trend, a signal to markets that a hike was coming.

Charles Evans, a former Chicago Fed president who championed strong forward guidance after the 2007 to 2009 financial crisis, said to economists in Cleveland this week that transparency about how the central bank pursues its objective is important. A macro strategist at an investment manager said remarks from Jefferson and Williams allowed Warsh to get his message across without being the channel for it. She said she is willing to give him time to find the right form of communication, noting that the value of communication has become apparent in recent months.