Key Highlights

  • Florida asked a Pasco County judge on Oct. 7 for a temporary injunction against Facebook and Instagram.
  • The filing seeks removal of users under 14 and a two-hour daily limit for teens across all Meta apps.
  • Meta settled with 48 states and Washington, DC, in August, agreeing to pay up to USD 18 billion.
  • That payout equals about three to four months of Meta's profit and about one month of its revenue.

The Injunction Request

Florida asked a state judge on Wednesday to order changes to Instagram and Facebook to better protect young users, as it presses ahead with a lawsuit accusing Meta Platforms (NASDAQ:META) of harming teens. Most states have resolved similar claims through a sweeping settlement.

In a filing in a Pasco County court, Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier asked for a temporary injunction that would force Meta to identify and remove users in the state under the age of 14 from the platforms. It would also limit teens there to two hours a day across all of Meta's apps and turn off features such as autoplay and infinite scroll for them. The filing asked that the changes take effect immediately and stay in place while the lawsuit moves forward.

The changes Uthmeier seeks are more stringent than those Meta agreed to in the multistate settlement. They would cut off teens' access to messaging once their time limits are reached and bar the company from showing them advertisements.

Settlement Backdrop and Meta's Response

Florida's lawsuit accuses Meta of knowingly engineering its platforms to be addictive for young users and of misleading consumers about their safety. It was one of dozens of similar suits filed by states across the country. Florida first sued in October 2023, under then Attorney General Ashley Moody, when dozens of other states also took Meta to court, according to reporting at the time. In August, Meta settled with 48 other states and Washington, DC, agreeing to pay up to USD 18 billion and make changes for teen users of its platforms. Meta has said it works hard to keep teens safe and denied wrongdoing in agreeing to settle. The total payout represents about three to four months of profit and about one month of Revenue for the company.

Uthmeier, a Republican, opted not to join the settlement and proceed with Florida's case. The state said in the filing that the settlement amounted to a "mere slap on the wrist" that would be viewed as "the cost of doing business" and would not prevent such behavior going forward.

A Meta spokesperson said that after the company's settlement with nearly every other state, Florida should focus on getting other platforms to take action. "The attorney general should be using taxpayer resources to get YouTube and TikTok to empower parents and protect teens in Florida. We regret that he has chosen instead to pursue a meritless preliminary injunction years into the litigation," the spokesperson said.

Court Developments to Follow

The points to watch are the Pasco County judge's handling of the injunction request, Meta's formal response to the filing, and how the settlement terms compare with the stricter measures Florida is seeking for its teen users.