Key Highlights
- Since 1957, nearly every US president has left the stock market in better shape than when they took office, with two notable exceptions.
- Midterm years have historically shown the largest average market pullbacks of any year within a four year presidential cycle.
- The S&P 500 has averaged annual returns of about 12 percent under Democratic presidents compared with about 8 percent under Republican presidents since 1951.
- A split Congress, where each chamber is controlled by a different party, has historically produced the strongest average stock market returns.
Long Term Market Trends Favor Steady Growth Regardless of Party
As prediction markets and polling point toward a potential shift in Congressional control following November's midterm elections, historical data suggests that the eventual outcome may have less bearing on stock market performance than many investors assume. Since 1957, nearly every US president has left the broad stock market in stronger condition than when they entered office, with two notable exceptions tied to resignation and a term ending amid financial crisis.
Market strategists note that underlying economic fundamentals, including corporate earnings, Federal Reserve policy and inflation trends, tend to matter considerably more for long term returns than which political party holds power in Washington.
Midterm Years Bring Volatility but Also Strong Rebounds
Despite the generally positive long term trend, midterm years have historically shown the largest average stock market pullbacks of any year within a four year presidential cycle, based on data spanning 1950 through 2025. Notably, these larger average declines have also been followed by the strongest average rebounds over the subsequent twelve months, a pattern that complicates efforts to time market entries around political events.
Market strategists generally caution against attempting to adjust portfolios based on anticipated election outcomes, instead favoring a consistent, diversified investment approach that allows returns to compound over longer periods regardless of short term political developments.
Party Control Shows Limited Correlation With Sector Performance
Specific sector expectations tied to election outcomes have frequently failed to materialize. Clean energy stocks did not see the anticipated boost following a change in presidential administration associated with environmental policy priorities, while coal related investments did not benefit as expected under an administration publicly supportive of the industry, with broader market indices outperforming both groups over the relevant periods.
Data since 1951 shows average annual S&P 500 returns of about 12 percent under Democratic presidents compared with about 8 percent under Republican presidents, though Republican controlled Congresses have historically outperformed Democratic led legislatures. A split Congress, in which each chamber is controlled by a different party, has produced the strongest average returns of any Congressional configuration, a pattern some strategists attribute to legislative gridlock limiting the pace of new federal spending.
Election and Market Metrics to Watch
The outcome of House and Senate races in November, subsequent Federal Reserve policy decisions, and corporate earnings trends through year end may together shape near term market direction more than the election result itself. Historical patterns suggest that any midterm related volatility could be followed by a recovery over the following twelve months, though past patterns do not guarantee future outcomes.






Please wait processing your request...