Key Highlights

● Strong third-quarter GDP and hotter September Inflation gave Fed hawks fresh ammunition.

● The Fed held rates steady by a 10–2 vote, with two dissents for a hike.

● The Fed statement upgraded economic activity to expanding at a strong pace.

● Friday's Employment Cost index is the next checkpoint before the December 8–9 meeting.

A hotter-than-expected growth report and firmer inflation readings on Thursday gave Fed hawks fresh ammunition, and at least one Wall Street strategist said so plainly.

One sentence that summed up the morning

Thursday's 8:30am data dump arrived barely 18 hours after the Federal Reserve left rates unchanged, and it did nothing to calm the hawks. Within hours, one Wealth advisor offered a verdict that captured the mood on many trading desks: "Today's data strengthens the case for another rate increase in December," he said, according to market commentary.

The remark landed because it connected two things that markets had been weighing separately: a Central Bank that had just paused after a September hike, and an economy that refuses to slow down.

What the data actually showed

The advance estimate of third-quarter GDP showed growth accelerating sharply from the second quarter and beating forecasts, although sources differed on exactly what economists had expected. Business Investment soared and consumer spending stayed sturdy, according to media reports.

At the same time, September's personal consumption expenditures report showed headline inflation heating up from August, with Core Inflation also edging higher, according to market data. Energy and gasoline prices jumped during the month, which one source tied to a war-related squeeze in oil.

One source said the PCE readings matched estimates, while another said the headline figure came in slightly below consensus. Either way, the direction was the problem: inflation is moving away from the Fed's goal, not toward it.

Why December suddenly looks live

On Wednesday the Fed held rates steady by a 10–2 vote. Governor Lisa Cook and Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack both dissented in favor of a hike, according to media reports. The statement also upgraded the description of economic activity to "expanding at a strong pace," replacing the earlier word "solid."

Chair Kevin Warsh was blunt in his press conference. "It's our responsibility to get inflation down," he said, according to media reports.

Futures markets had already leaned hawkish. Futures-market data showed traders heavily favoring a December hike on Wednesday, and the odds held at similarly lofty levels Thursday morning, according to media reports. Not every report agreed, however: one source flagged that another report described expectations as leaning toward a pause, so the picture of market pricing was not unanimous.

The economist's comment captured the logic for the hawkish camp. A Fed that just told the world the economy is expanding at a strong pace, and then watched inflation tick up the next morning, has fewer reasons to stay on hold.

How markets took it

Stocks did not trade on the Fed story alone. Alphabet (NASDAQ:GOOGL)'s historic plunge dragged the Nasdaq Composite down 365.13 points to 26,184.72, while the S&P 500 slipped 23.59 points to 7,720.39 and the Dow lost 132.54 points to 52,342.56. Beneath the surface, though, more than 400 S&P 500 members closed higher, and the Russell 2000 jumped 28.71 points to 2,859.22.

Treasury yields eased rather than spiking, with the 10-year yield slipping just below the closely watched threshold it had reclaimed a day earlier. Gold fell as rate-hike bets firmed, according to one source, which said strong growth and hot inflation support Fed tightening bets.

What to watch

The next major checkpoint arrives Friday at 8:30am with the third-quarter Employment Cost Index, a key gauge of wage pressure. A strong reading would add weight to the economist's argument; a soft one could give doves something to work with.

Beyond that, the Fed's final decision of the year comes December 8–9. Between now and then, investors will parse every inflation and jobs report for signs that the economy is cooling. So far, Thursday's numbers pointed the other way.