Key Highlights

  • Job openings came in at 7.079 million, below forecasts of about 7.2 million and the lowest reading since March.
  • July's figure was revised up to 7.335 million, which made the August drop look even sharper.
  • Cory Stahle of Indeed said the labor market is far less dynamic than it was a few years ago.
  • Layoffs fell and quits retreated slightly, describing a labor market with little churn for those already employed.

Fresh government data showed US job openings sliding to their lowest level since March, and an Indeed economist said the market is comfortable for those with jobs but frustrating for those who are searching.

Still standing, with less bounce

America's job market is still standing, but it has lost much of its bounce. That was the message from Tuesday's Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey, better known as JOLTS, which showed employers advertising fewer positions in August than economists had expected.

Job openings came in at 7.079 million, below forecasts of about 7.2 million and the lowest reading since March. July's figure was revised up to 7.335 million, which made the August drop look even sharper.

Cory Stahle, senior economist at Indeed, summed up the mood. The labor market, he said, is "far less dynamic than it was a few years ago. It's a comfortable place to be if you already have a job. It's a frustrating one if you're trying to find one."

A market that has stopped moving

Stahle's point goes beyond the headline number. The same report showed that layoffs fell and quits retreated slightly. That combination describes a labor market with little churn.

Low layoffs are good news for people who already have a paycheck. But fewer quits usually means workers are less confident about finding something better, and fewer openings means fewer doors for anyone trying to get in. Recent graduates, people re-entering the workforce and those who have lost a job face a narrower set of options than they did a few years ago, when employers were competing hard for staff.

That is why economists pay close attention to the flow of workers, not just the total count of jobs. A market can look stable on paper while becoming harder to navigate for those on the outside.

Consumers are feeling it too

The JOLTS report landed alongside another sobering reading. The Conference Board's consumer confidence index fell to 81.9 in September from 88.6 in August, well below the 89.2 forecast and its lowest level since 2014.

Jeffrey Roach, chief economist at LPL Financial (NASDAQ:LPLA), said that "Americans feel jobs are more scarce and are pulling back on plans for homes, cars, and big-ticket purchases, emitting a warning sign for holiday spending."

Together, the two releases painted a picture of workers who are holding on to what they have and spending more carefully.

How markets reacted

Wall Street spent the day more focused on bond yields than on jobs. The 30-year Treasury yield climbed to its highest level since 2002, and the 10-year yield touched its highest level in roughly two decades. The S&P 500 slipped 12.85 points to 7,670.84, the Dow fell 131.59 points to 51,349.92, and the Nasdaq Composite ended essentially flat to slightly lower at 26,797.54.

The dollar index rose to about 101.50 and hit fresh multi-week highs after the JOLTS release.

The softer data also fed into the debate at the Federal Reserve, which raised rates at its September meeting. New York Fed President John Williams said on Tuesday that "there is no need for urgency," and traders cut the odds of an October hike to roughly a coin flip, according to several reports.

Payrolls and the Fed: Testing a Cooling Job Market

The next big test for the job market arrives Friday, October 2, with the September jobs report. Economists expect about 95,000 new jobs.

Before that, Wednesday, September 30 brings the third estimate of GDP and August PCE inflation data, the Fed's preferred inflation gauge. The Fed's next policy meeting is October 27 and 28, where the question of whether a cooling job market is enough to offset stubborn inflation will be front and center.