Key Highlights
- Cleveland-Cliffs (NYSE:CLF) fell between about 6% and 6.9% on Tuesday, October 20, 2026, a day after a 16% jump on 2027 adjusted EBITDA guidance above USD 4 billion.
- Steel Dynamics (NASDAQ:STLD) earned USD 5.26 a share on record shipments of 3.8 million tons, below its own guidance of USD 5.34 to USD 5.38, and fell in Tuesday trading.
- iShares MSCI Canada ETF (NYSEARCA:EWC) gained a legal variable on October 20, when a US food importer sued in the Court of International Trade to block 50% tariffs on Canadian goods.
- Trade policy frames all three: a 50% tariff on imported steel supports US prices and Cleveland-Cliffs has suspended some Canadian operations citing duties, while Nucor (NYSE:NUE) held steady.
Cleveland-Cliffs (NYSE:CLF): a round trip on guidance and leverage
Cleveland-Cliffs (NYSE:CLF), the largest flat-rolled steel producer in North America and a major supplier to carmakers, fell between about 6% and 6.9% on Tuesday, October 20, 2026. On Monday the shares had jumped about 16% after third-quarter adjusted earnings of USD 0.28 per share beat estimates of USD 0.19 to USD 0.22. Revenue of USD 5.6 billion missed consensus of about USD 5.72 billion. The company guided to 2027 adjusted EBITDA above USD 4 billion, against analyst forecasts near USD 2.6 billion. The company made no new announcement on Tuesday.
The 2027 figure depends on automotive contract resets and on prevailing steel price forecasts, and the 50% tariff on imported steel is part of what supports those domestic prices. Part of the rally therefore priced an outcome more than a year away and partly dependent on trade policy. The next question is leverage: EBITDA, meaning earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation, can recover quickly, but equity holders benefit only once debt falls. Nucor held steady while Cleveland-Cliffs fell, so the reversal looked like positioning in one stock rather than a sector retreat.
Tariffs also cut the other way. The company has suspended some operations at its Stelco plant in Hamilton, Ontario, citing duties, which ties it directly to the US and Canada dispute. Steel prices below the forecasts behind the 2027 outlook, slow debt reduction and higher interest rates are the other named risks. Management has pointed to a major debt reduction in the fourth quarter, which makes that payment a test. A 16% gain followed by a 6% to 6.9% fall still leaves the shares about 8% to 9% above the Friday close, calculated from reported moves.
Steel Dynamics (NASDAQ:STLD): record tons, narrower spreads
Steel Dynamics (NASDAQ:STLD), which melts scrap in electric arc furnaces and runs metals recycling, steel fabrication and aluminium businesses, reported third-quarter results after the close on Monday, October 19, 2026. Net income was USD 756 million, or USD 5.26 per diluted share, against USD 3.69 in the second quarter and USD 2.74 a year earlier. Net sales of USD 6.5 billion beat forecasts and shipments reached a record 3.8 million tons, but earnings fell short of September guidance and a consensus estimate of USD 5.42. The shares fell about 5.8% premarket on Tuesday and as much as 8% later, although at least one intraday quote showed a gain.
Steel profits depend on the metal spread, the gap between the selling price of steel and the cost of scrap or iron ore. Record volumes help only if spreads hold, and a miss of about 1.5% against the bottom of guidance points to costs or pricing, not demand, calculated from published figures. The September guidance flagged narrower spreads in metals recycling, and because that arm sells scrap that mills buy, weaker recycling profits offset part of the steel gain. The tariff wall lifts the domestic selling price but does not set scrap costs.
The first risk is spread compression if scrap costs rise faster than steel prices. The second is demand from construction and manufacturing, which tends to soften when rates rise, after a poll of economists published on October 20 showed most economists expect a Fed hike in December. The third is that the 50% steel tariff can change. Fabrication backlog, reported nearly 50% above a year earlier, offers some support for volumes. Investors should watch Nucor commentary and the company's mid-quarter guidance, which last came on Thursday, September 17.
iShares MSCI Canada ETF (NYSEARCA:EWC): the other side of the tariff wall
iShares MSCI Canada ETF (NYSEARCA:EWC) holds large Canadian companies, many of which sell heavily into the United States. On Tuesday, October 20, 2026, a US food importer filed suit in the US Court of International Trade to block 50% tariffs on Canadian goods imposed under Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930. The Liberty Justice Center, which brings the case, argues the provision was superseded by later trade law. The duties first hit dairy, alcoholic beverages and motor vehicles in July, were extended in September and escalated toward import bans.
Section 338 duties and the steel tariff are separate measures, though both are set at 50%, and the lawsuit addresses only the Canadian duties. The link to US steel runs through cars: duties on Canadian motor vehicles touch the same integrated auto supply chain that buys flat-rolled steel. For the fund, tariffs act through lower US sales volumes, thinner export margins and a weaker Canadian dollar, which slid in late August as talks with Washington broke down. The fund is priced in US dollars while its holdings earn mostly in Canadian dollars, so currency moves pass straight into returns.
The main risk is that the case takes months and the administration shifts to another legal authority even if it loses. A fast preliminary injunction, a court order pausing the duties, would cut costs for importers quickly. The fund's heavy weights in banks and energy producers also dilute the direct tariff effect. Escalation toward import bans could widen the damage to Canadian exporters, and a ruling could face appeal, delaying relief. The case has also been characterised as a class action.
Where Things Stand
The answer is that tariffs set the backdrop for North American steel but did not decide this week's moves, which came from positioning and margins. Cleveland-Cliffs (NYSE:CLF) gave back part of a guidance rally that rests on tariff-supported prices, while Steel Dynamics (NASDAQ:STLD) showed that protected prices cannot offset narrower scrap spreads. iShares MSCI Canada ETF (NYSEARCA:EWC) sits on the other side of the wall, where the Section 338 case is a slow route to relief. The next catalysts are court scheduling orders, Nucor commentary, the Fed decision on Wednesday, October 28 and fourth-quarter debt repayment at Cleveland-Cliffs. Guidance and court outcomes are not guarantees, and this is not investment advice.






Please wait processing your request...