Key Highlights

  • The first index fund launched 50 years ago with just over $11 million, far short of its initial fundraising target
  • More than half of net Assets overseen by American Investment funds are now held in index trackers, rising to 64% for funds focused on domestic stocks
  • Choosing which index to track, and how a fund manages sampling, rebalancing, and taxable gains, involves significant active decision-making despite the passive label
  • Research including the 'inelastic markets hypothesis' suggests index fund flows may meaningfully distort broader stock prices

First Index Fund Marks 50 Years Since Rocky Launch

The launch of the first index fund available to individual investors, fifty years ago this month, did not go smoothly. Its founder had hoped to raise between $50 million and $150 million but collected only a little over $11 million, describing the launch at the time as an outright failure. As the first fund designed simply to track a stock market index, in this case the S&P 500, the concept drew skepticism, with a contemporary industry publication dismissing Index Funds as a fad that would soon disappear.

Half a century later, there is no sign of that prediction coming true. More than half of net assets overseen by American investment funds are now held in index trackers, according to the Investment Company Institute, an industry group. For funds focused specifically on domestic stocks, that share rises to 64%, meaning most investors, whether through personal savings, a workplace pension, or a university endowment, likely hold a stake in at least one index fund.

Debate Persists Over Whether Index Funds Are Truly Passive

Professional stock pickers, whose performance has often lagged low-cost trackers, remain critical of the index fund model. Yet the idea that index funds are entirely passive is increasingly disputed. Over the past five decades, these vehicles have reshaped markets, and investing in one still involves a range of active choices, starting with which index to track. Investors seeking European Equity exposure, for example, must choose between indices covering dozens or hundreds of companies, each representing a meaningfully different investment.

Even index funds themselves are not entirely passive in their construction and operation. Fund managers retain discretion over how closely a fund replicates its target index, sometimes sampling a subset of underlying securities rather than holding every constituent, particularly for funds tracking very broad indices. Managers can also trade to minimize taxable gains, manage the impact of periodic rebalancing, or generate additional returns by lending held securities to short sellers.

Research Raises Questions About Index Funds' Market Impact

A growing body of research suggests index funds may meaningfully influence broader asset prices, not simply because of their scale but because of how consistently they must transact. One widely circulated theory, known as the inelastic markets hypothesis, has found evidence that fixed-allocation funds can cause a dollar flowing into the stock market to raise overall Market Value by several dollars. Other research has suggested that flows into index funds disproportionately lift the share prices of the largest constituent companies.

Even if index fund popularity is contributing to elevated market valuations or reinforcing the dominance of a small number of large companies, that dynamic is not necessarily an argument against holding them. When markets eventually decline, as when they rise, index trackers will reflect the market average, generally outperforming the average individual stock picker after accounting for fees.