Key Highlights

  • S&P 500 companies reported $2.64 trillion in combined Net Income over the trailing four quarters, with a significant portion tied to Investment markups.
  • Other income tied largely to investment gains totaled roughly $121 billion combined at Alphabet and Amazon last quarter.
  • Investment gains made up 71% of Alphabet's quarterly profit and 66% of Amazon's.
  • Excluding Amazon and Alphabet, trailing four-quarter S&P 500 Earnings growth stands at 24%, still a strong pace.

Paper Gains Blur the Earnings Picture

Corporate profits across the S&P 500 have surged, but a substantial share of that growth reflects unrealized gains rather than core operating performance. S&P 500 companies reported a combined $2.64 trillion in net income over the trailing four quarters, according to data compiled by S&P Global Market Intelligence, with a significant portion of that total coming from paper gains tied to marking up Equity investments in other companies.

Last quarter, other income at Amazon (NASDAQ:AMZN) and Alphabet (NASDAQ:GOOGL) totaled roughly $121 billion combined after taxes, almost entirely stemming from investment gains. Alphabet's share of that figure is on track to represent about 10% of second-quarter earnings for the entire S&P 500, with Amazon's share adding another 5%. Other income made up 71% of Alphabet's quarterly profit and 66% of Amazon's. Alphabet's gains stemmed largely from revaluing equity holdings that include stakes in SpaceX and Anthropic, the artificial intelligence developer behind the Claude chatbot, while Amazon's markups came primarily from its own stake in Anthropic.

These figures illustrate how much of the recent earnings surge at both companies is attributable to paper gains rather than core operations, a distinction that matters greatly for anyone assessing the underlying strength of their businesses.

Inconsistent Treatment Distorts Comparisons

These investment gains qualify as net income under generally accepted accounting principles, but analysts caution against applying typical market valuation multiples to earnings inflated by unrealized, nonrecurring paper profits. Even accounting for these gains, the S&P 500 trades at roughly 27 times trailing earnings, well above its historical average of about 16 times.

The inconsistency stems from a lack of a unified approach among Wall Street analysts for handling investment markups. Last quarter, Nvidia (NASDAQ:NVDA) steered analysts to exclude similar unrealized gains from its adjusted results, and analysts complied, while Alphabet and Amazon did not direct a similar exclusion, and analysts included the gains in what is commonly called Street earnings. Street earnings represent whichever profit metric a majority of analysts covering a company adopt, whether GAAP or non-GAAP, and these figures feed into widely used earnings data for the S&P 500 and other major indexes.

For most S&P 500 companies, non-GAAP earnings remain the preferred metric among covering analysts. One major semiconductor company reported $9.3 billion in net income last quarter but $12.1 billion in non-GAAP earnings after excluding stock-based compensation and amortization of intangible assets, both recurring operating expenses that analysts nonetheless left out of their adjusted figures. According to FactSet data, Street earnings exclude stock-based compensation for at least 65 companies within the S&P 500.

Distortions Extend to Forward Estimates

The inconsistency also affects forward-looking valuations. The S&P 500 currently trades at 19 times FactSet's 2027 consensus earnings estimate, a figure based on Street earnings projections rather than GAAP figures. On a trailing basis, the index trades at 24 times Street earnings, a lower multiple than one based on GAAP net income, largely because analysts chose not to exclude the outsized markups at Alphabet and Amazon from their Street earnings calculations.

On a trailing four-quarter basis, S&P 500 earnings are up 31% from the year-earlier period under GAAP accounting. Excluding Amazon and Alphabet, that growth rate falls to 24%, still a robust pace of expansion. With markets trading near historical highs, the inconsistent treatment of investment gains makes it more difficult for investors to distinguish genuine operating strength from accounting-driven earnings boosts.