Key Highlights

  • Retail money-market funds hold more than $3 trillion in assets, hovering near a record high, according to the Investment Company Institute
  • Money-market funds now Yield an average of 3.49%, down from levels above 5% in recent years but still retaining strong investor appeal
  • Wealth managers are pitching alternatives including corporate bonds, municipal bonds, and buffer Exchange-traded funds to help investors put cash to work
  • Some advisers argue investors who stay in cash risk having their returns Fail to keep pace with Inflation over time

Investors Resist Pressure to Redeploy Record Cash Holdings

Individual investors are sitting on a mountain of cash, with more than $3 trillion held in retail money-market funds, hovering around a record high according to the Investment Company Institute, a figure that does not include the trillions of institutional dollars held in similar funds. Assets flooded into these funds in 2022 when the Federal Reserve ended its policy of near-zero interest rates, and although money-market yields have since fallen from levels above 5%, the funds have retained strong appeal among investors, now yielding an average of 3.49%.

Wealth and asset managers, eager to prove their value and in many cases earn additional fees, are working to convince investors to redeploy that cash. The argument centers on the risk that cash yields will fail to keep pace with inflation over time, with money-market yields currently sitting close to the rate of inflation itself.

Advisers Pitch Bond Ladders and Buffer ETFs as Alternatives

Many advisers are pitching alternatives including corporate bonds, municipal bonds, and more exotic offerings such as buffer exchange-traded funds and private credit. One chief financial and investment officer recommended investors consider locking in historically high yields in investment-grade corporate bonds by building a ladder of investments with staggered maturities, arguing that longer-duration bonds allow investors to secure current yields for an extended period and guard against future rate declines, unlike money-market funds, savings accounts, and certificates of deposit, whose yields tend to fall alongside prevailing rates.

The same adviser also favors high-quality municipal bond funds yielding around 4%, which are typically exempt from federal income taxes and can also be exempt from state taxes, describing them as an attractive option for investors concerned about US Treasury bonds given the country's widening budget deficit.

Buffer ETFs Offer Downside Protection at a Cost

Some advisers have turned to buffer ETFs, which use Options strategies to limit downside risk while also capping potential upside, typically over a specific timeframe such as 12 months. One Wealth manager builds a laddered portfolio of such funds with staggered reset dates and maturities, noting they tend to be more expensive than typical ETFs but can offer comparable protection to a structured note from a bank at a lower cost. Even so, the manager acknowledged that if the stock market underperforms money-market yields over the relevant period, investors would have been better off simply staying in cash.

Not all investors are convinced. One retired airline pilot who keeps 85% of his portfolio in stocks and the remainder in a money-market fund said he prefers to rely on historical patterns in Bear Market length to manage his own cash needs, selling stocks to replenish cash only when necessary, and remains skeptical of complex investment products carrying higher fees.