Key Highlights
- A federal judge ruled the Justice Department’s effort to check state voter rolls against an immigration database was unlawful.
- The 78-page decision sided with a watchdog group’s challenge and found the department downplayed the risk of disenfranchising eligible citizens.
- Federal law bars systematic voter-roll reviews in the 90 days before an election, which includes the midterms.
- In June the same judge blocked use of an expanded SAVE database; the Supreme Court paused that order last month.
What the Judge Decided
US District Judge Sparkle Sooknanan ruled on Friday that the Justice Department’s effort to obtain state voter rolls and run them against a federal immigration database was unlawful. The department had used the checks to Demand that states remove voters it deemed ineligible. The decision is the latest setback for President Donald Trump’s push to expand federal control over election administration ahead of the November 3 midterms, in which his Republican Party is fighting to keep majorities in both houses of Congress.
In a 78-page opinion siding with a watchdog group’s challenge, Sooknanan wrote that the department downplayed the risk that its practice risked wrongly disenfranchising eligible citizens, despite evidence pointing to inaccuracies in the immigration database, known as SAVE. “The challenged policy represents the federal government’s attempt to decide who gets to vote,” she wrote. “But Congress has left that authority where our Constitution has always placed it: with the states.”
Sooknanan, who sits in Washington, was appointed by President Joe Biden. The Justice Department did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The Database at the Center
SAVE stands for Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements, a federal tool that election officials have used to check voter rolls for noncitizens. In 2025, federal agencies made it free for election officials, allowed bulk searches and began accepting names, birthdates and Social Security numbers. At least 25 states have used it since April 2025, and at least 67 million registrations have been scanned.
A Second Ruling From the Same Judge
In a separate case in June, Sooknanan blocked the administration from using an expanded version of SAVE to check the accuracy of voter rolls. Brought by the League of Women Voters, a privacy group and five US citizens, that case produced findings that the system had flagged some lawful voters as noncitizens and that Congress had barred the centralizing of Americans’ personal identifying information. The Supreme Court last month temporarily paused that decision. The Justice Department said at the time that it intends to keep defending the use of SAVE.
The 90-Day Window
Federal election law prohibits the systematic review of voter rolls in the 90 days before any federal election. The current period falls inside that window, which bears on how far either Sooknanan’s new ruling or the Supreme Court’s pause reaches in the run-up to the midterms.






Please wait processing your request...