Key Highlights
- Two small businesses filed a lawsuit challenging new tariffs of 10 and 12.5 percent on 60 trading partners.
- The lawsuit argues the tariffs, imposed under Section 301, exceed the president's legal authority.
- The new tariffs took effect the same day a temporary 10 percent global tariff expired.
- A Democratic state attorney general said his state is considering joining a third legal challenge.
A New Legal Challenge Follows a Pattern of Court Losses
Two US small businesses filed a lawsuit in the US Court of International Trade challenging President Trump's latest round of tariffs on goods from 60 trading partners, arguing that the new policy, like most of Trump's previous tariffs, exceeds the president's authority to tax imports. The lawsuit contends that the new tariffs require more detailed country specific findings about unfair trade practices to be legally justified.
The businesses, backed by a nonprofit legal group that successfully sued over previous rounds of tariffs, argue that the administration is attempting to re-impose tariffs that were already ruled illegal by the US Supreme Court. The new tariffs of 10 and 12.5 percent on 60 trading partners, including the European Union, took effect Friday over allegations that these countries were not doing enough to stop the export of goods produced with forced labor, just as a temporary 10 percent global tariff expired.
Section 301 Authority Faces a Novel Legal Test
The latest tariffs were imposed under Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974, a legal authority meant to combat unfair or discriminatory economic practices by other nations. Unlike the International Emergency Economic Powers Act or the temporary global tariff authority that the Supreme Court and US trade court have both previously ruled against, Section 301 has been used regularly by past presidents, giving it a stronger legal foundation on its face.
However, the small businesses argue in their lawsuit that Section 301 tariffs have historically been targeted to address specific nations and industries, and that Trump's broad brush approach applying preestablished rates across dozens of countries simultaneously has no historical precedent. Jeffrey Schwab, an attorney at the Liberty Justice Center representing the businesses, said Section 301 does not include any authority to tax substantially all imports from substantially all countries at preestablished rates. The lawsuit asks the trade court to declare the tariffs unlawful, prevent their enforcement, and preserve importers' ability to receive refunds for any tariffs found to be illegal. The two plaintiffs, Burlap and Barrel, a spice importer that previously challenged Trump's temporary global tariff, and Collective Horology, a California watch retailer, are continuing a pattern of small business led legal challenges to the administration's trade policy.
Balancing Precedent From Prior Rulings Against Section 301's Established History
The lawsuit's outcome will likely hinge on how the trade court interprets the scope of Section 301 authority relative to its historical use by past presidents for narrower, country specific trade actions. Given that both the Supreme Court and the US trade court have already ruled against the administration's two prior tariff justifications, a favorable precedent for challengers exists, though Section 301's more established legal history could provide the administration a stronger footing than in previous cases.
Adding a further dimension to the legal landscape, Oregon Attorney General Dan Rayfield indicated his state is considering joining a third legal challenge to Trump's tariffs, following the pattern of Democratic led states joining the two previous lawsuits. Rayfield argued the new tariffs will drive up costs for everyday Americans while doing nothing to combat forced labor overseas, suggesting continued political and legal pressure on the administration's tariff strategy regardless of this particular case's outcome.
Conclusion
The latest lawsuit against Trump's tariffs tests whether Section 301, a more established legal authority than the previously struck down IEEPA and temporary global tariff powers, can support the administration's broad application of tariffs across 60 trading partners simultaneously. Whether the trade court extends its prior skepticism of the administration's tariff approach to this new legal basis may determine the durability of the current tariff regime. With potential additional legal challenges from state attorneys general also on the horizon, the tariff policy's legal foundation is likely to remain contested in the courts for the foreseeable future.






Please wait processing your request...