Key Highlights

  • The justices turned away Google’s appeal of a ruling that left the patent office’s “settled expectations” rule in place.
  • The rule lets the patent board reject review requests for patents in force more than six years.
  • The share of reviews the board takes up fell to 37 percent in 2026, from 65 percent before.
  • A separate suit by Google, Apple and Intel lost in February, and Intel and Google seek Supreme Court review.

The Court Turns Google Away

The US Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear a challenge by Alphabet’s Google (NASDAQ:GOOGL) to a US Patent and Trademark Office rule. The company argues the rule has insulated older patents from validity reviews and helped fuel a surge in patent litigation.

The justices turned away Google’s appeal of a lower court’s decision not to force the agency to reconsider, without using its “settled expectations” rule, the company’s challenge to the validity of a patent held by software company VirtaMove. The patent involves server software, and VirtaMove accused Google of infringing it.

How the Rule Works

Technology companies often use “inter partes review”, a process run by the agency’s Patent Trial and Appeal Board, to try to cancel patents they are accused of infringing. The board is the agency’s in-house tribunal for challenges to issued patents, and the Federal Circuit hears appeals in patent cases. Under the “settled expectations” policy, the board became quicker to reject requests to review patents that have been in force for more than six years.

The agency outlined in a memo last year several factors that favor rejecting a review petition. It has used them to deny review for patents more than six years old, based on the “settled expectations” of the parties. It cited the rule in rejecting Google’s petition in 2025 over the VirtaMove patent, and the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit then ruled against Google’s appeal of that rejection.

A company that cannot get a patent reviewed at the board must challenge its validity in court, where the burden of proof is higher. Samsung, Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL) and Alphabet were the three most active petitioners at the board between 2020 and 2025, an industry report found.

Review Rates Fall

The Trump administration has introduced measures at the patent office that decreased the percentage of reviews the board takes up. That figure fell to 37 percent in 2026 under John Squires, the Trump appointee who heads the agency, compared with 65 percent under his predecessor Kathi Vidal, who was appointed by former President Joe Biden, an April agency report showed.

The shift began in 2025. Industry data show quarterly institution rates at the board slid from 68 percent in the first quarter of 2025 to 23 percent in the third. In February 2025 the agency’s then acting director withdrew guidance from 2022 that had limited discretionary denials. In March 2025 the director took over discretionary denial decisions under an expanded set of factors, and Squires took over decisions on whether to institute reviews in October 2025.

Google’s Argument

Google said in a filing to the justices that the rule exceeds the patent office’s authority by creating an artificial time limit for board petitions. “The PTO (Patent and Trademark Office) has no authority to create a limitations period where Congress did not, and it has no authority to expand patent rights beyond what Congress provided,” the company said.

The Trump administration urged the court not to hear Google’s appeal.

A Second Case in the Wings

A group of companies including Google, Apple and Intel (NASDAQ:INTC) has filed a separate lawsuit challenging a related patent office policy. The Federal Circuit ruled against the companies in February, and Intel and Google have also asked the Supreme Court to hear that case.

That petition is distinct from the one the court rejected on Monday.