Key Highlights
- US government debt has passed USD 40 trillion, and the 10-year Treasury yield remains above 5 percent.
- Treasury counselor David Zervos called the IMF's past forecasts "messy" and urged taking them "with a grain of salt."
- IMF Managing Director Kristalina Georgieva said growth alone is not enough to put US debt on a sustainable course.
- Global debt topped USD 365 trillion in the first half of the year, a global industry association reported.
A Response From the Treasury
David Zervos, the newly appointed counselor to the Treasury Secretary, urged the International Monetary Fund on Thursday to check its own forecasting record before criticizing US fiscal policy. "When we see pieces on the IMF, it's good to remember how messy their forecasts have been in the past," Zervos said in emailed comments. He is a former Wall Street economist and market strategist.
He was responding to IMF Managing Director Kristalina Georgieva, who cautioned on Wednesday, during the IMF-World Bank annual meetings in Bangkok, that strong US economic growth is not enough to put mounting federal debt on a sustainable course.
Where the Debate Began
Georgieva was herself responding to Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, who in an August interview pointed to growth as a way to "grow our way out" of a rising debt-to-GDP ratio, after government debt surpassed USD 40 trillion. The exchange comes as the 10-year Treasury yield remains above 5 percent, and on Thursday that yield fell almost 13 basis points to 5.066 percent as investors moved from technology shares into bonds. Scrutiny of the fiscal outlook has intensified as a result.
The Forecasting Record Zervos Cited
Zervos pointed to several episodes. "In 2008, [the IMF's World Economic Outlook] had world growth at 3 percent and we had the first global contraction in post-world history a year later. We saw them positive on Southeast Asia in 1997 before the collapse."
He continued: "We saw them very negative on Russia in 2022, and Russia actually barely saw a blip down in growth before it started growing strongly. We saw them very positive on Argentina after their big bailout of USD 57 billion. And by 2020, Argentina was basically in default again. And the history books go on and on, whether it's Greece, whether it was the transitory call on inflation in the U.S." He added: "So take it all with a grain of salt."
A Wider Debate Over Debt
Many economists warn that mounting US interest payments and a high deficit have raised the risk of an unsustainable debt spiral, though they are divided on whether the country faces the risk of a true fiscal crisis. Georgieva has issued similar warnings to other large economies about fiscal consolidation. In an interview on October 7, she said her message to France was: "Get your house in order."
Other institutions are also pointing to the rising cost of servicing global debt, which topped USD 365 trillion in the first half of the year. A global financial industry association argued in a September report that a cycle of elections and short-term quick fixes to debt challenges was reducing the ability to spend money on public services.
The Same Meetings, Another Treasury Message
The IMF-World Bank meetings in Bangkok have also been the venue for Bessent's written statement to the steering committees of both institutions, in which the Treasury said the IMF must use its voice on global imbalances "or risk being sidelined."






Please wait processing your request...