Key Highlights
- FHFA Director Bill Pulte directed Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to approve all lenders to use VantageScore, expanding on an earlier rollout that saw 50 lenders adopt the Credit model.
- Shares of Fair Isaac, known as FICO, plunged 20% in early US trading following the announcement.
- Pulte separately criticized Equifax, Experian and TransUnion for what he called overcharging Americans, saying the administration is considering stronger reporting solutions.
- Shares of TransUnion and Equifax also fell, dropping 9% and 8% respectively, while London-listed Experian shed 4.6%.
A Push to Expand Credit Score Competition
US Director of Federal Housing Bill Pulte said he has directed Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the government-sponsored enterprises created by Congress to support the housing market, to approve all lenders to use the credit scoring system VantageScore. Pulte wrote in a Social Media post that the initial rollout of VantageScore had been incredibly successful, with 50 lenders already delivering loans using the model, and that he was instructing the agencies to approve all lenders effective immediately.
Pulte said FICO has enjoyed a Monopoly in the credit scoring space, declaring that this era is now over. Shares of Fair Isaac, better known as FICO, plunged 20% in early US trading on Friday following the announcement.
A Long-Running Campaign Against FICO's Dominance
Pulte's push to expand VantageScore's use comes even as he has separately criticized the three credit reporting agencies that jointly own the rival scoring system. In a separate post, Pulte said credit reporting agencies Equifax, Experian and TransUnion have been overcharging Americans for too long, adding that the administration is seriously considering a bi-merge credit reporting approach and other stronger solutions, which he referred to using the shorthand "SAFER and SOUNDER."
Shares of TransUnion slipped 9% and Equifax lost 8% in US trading following Pulte's comments, while London-listed Experian shed 4.6%. VantageScore, founded in 2006, is a credit score modeling and analytics company jointly owned by Equifax, Experian and TransUnion.
A Broader Push to Lower Homebuyer Costs
The Trump administration has said it intends to lower costs for American homebuyers and boost competition in the Mortgage credit scoring market, which has long been dominated by FICO. The push builds on a legal foundation established during Trump's first term, when he signed the Credit Score Competition Act into law in 2018, directing federal housing regulators to enable Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to approve more advanced credit score models for mortgage underwriting.
A Pattern of Sharp Market Reactions
Friday's stock declines extend a pattern seen throughout the year, as Pulte's public statements pressuring the credit bureau industry have repeatedly triggered sharp reactions in the shares of the affected companies. Whether the latest directive translates into a meaningful shift in Market Share away from FICO toward VantageScore, or simply adds another data point to an already volatile stock, will likely become clearer as more lenders begin using the expanded access in the months ahead.






Please wait processing your request...