Key Highlights

  • Fed officials made more than 40 public appearances since the September hike despite Chairman Warsh's call for a quieter Fed.
  • Consumer prices rose 3.7 percent in September from a year earlier, leaving an October hike seen as a coin toss.
  • Warsh speaks Friday at 0330 GMT at the IMF annual meeting in Bangkok, under two weeks before the Fed decision.
  • Warsh has pared forward guidance from the Fed statement and convened a task force on its rate-path projections.

A Chairman Who Prefers Silence

Federal Reserve Chairman Kevin Warsh has called for a "quieter" central bank. Colleagues who see public communication as a fundamental part of their job have pushed back on television, podcasts and social media. More than 40 appearances by nearly all of them since the September rate increase have persuaded traders to scale back rate-hike bets that had built up after that decision and Warsh's own silence on the path ahead.

Consumer prices rose 3.7 percent in September from a year earlier, data on Wednesday showed, shaking up expectations again. An October hike is now seen as a coin toss, a lack of clarity that sharpens the focus on Warsh's preference for silence.

The Case Against Guidance

In speeches at Sintra and Jackson Hole, in testimony and at press conferences, Warsh has argued that the less policymakers say about where rates are headed, the more markets must take cues from economic data, a better source of information for the Fed. He has pared forward guidance from the post-meeting statement and convened a task force on the quarterly rate-path projections, a staple of Fed communications for years. Observers widely anticipate that the group recommends dropping them.

Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack said in an interview on Monday that she is open to an argument that not speaking helps households and businesses make better decisions, but "I think it's a pretty hard argument to make."

Two of the Top Three Reset Expectations

Markets had been pricing a series of hikes at odds with the Fed's September dot plot, which showed a less aggressive path. Pointed remarks from New York Fed President John Williams and Fed Vice Chair Philip Jefferson were effective in resetting them. With the chair, they form the group typically seen as the three most influential policymakers. A former Fed vice chair now at an investment firm said markets took note that two of those three officials delivered a very consistent message.

Fed Governor Christopher Waller, speaking in Turkey last week, described what is needed as "additional rate hikes...(that) do not need to come at consecutive meetings, but they should be in place in an acceptable period of time." He said promising an exact rate path limits the Fed's ability to adjust to fresh information, a risk Warsh has also raised, but giving no signal at all "could surprise markets and create volatility."

Lessons From August

A similar gap opened in August, when markets bet heavily against a near-term hike after Warsh declined to give a detailed rationale for July's decision to hold rates steady despite what he called a "no tolerance" policy on inflation. That time Warsh himself broke the silence, saying he was not convinced a recent cooling in inflation marked a clear trend.

A macro strategist at an asset manager said they are willing to give Warsh some time to find the ideal form of communication.

Friday in Bangkok

Warsh speaks at the International Monetary Fund's annual meeting in Bangkok on Friday at 0330 GMT, which is 11:30 p.m. Eastern on Thursday. It is a final chance to shape expectations before the Fed's decision. The push for quiet comes as the Fed works to maintain its accountability amid White House efforts to influence its policy decisions.