Key Highlights

  • New Mexico asked a judge on October 1, 2026 to order Meta Platforms (NASDAQ:META) to pay between USD 35 billion and USD 40 billion in penalties after a Jury verdict on privacy misstatements.
  • Jurors found 26 of 29 statements misleading and more than 43 million violations of state consumer protection law, which allows up to USD 5,000 per violation.
  • Meta Platforms (NASDAQ:META) urged the judge to cap penalties at USD 3.45 billion, and the judge said he expected to rule later this month.
  • The state initially sought the maximum of USD 219 billion, then asked the court to reduce it on due process grounds.

How the Case Reached This Point

The lawsuit, filed by New Mexico in 2021, grew out of the Cambridge Analytica scandal, in which data from as many as 87 million Facebook users was harvested through a third-party app. A jury returned its verdict in Santa Fe in late September 2026, finding that the company and its leaders misled consumers about the privacy of their data. Judge Francis Mathew will set the financial penalty. At a hearing on October 1, he told the parties that those who go to trial accept the consequences of that decision.

The Penalty Math

State law allows a penalty of up to USD 5,000 for each violation. With more than 43 million violations found, the theoretical maximum is about USD 219 billion, which matches the figure the state first requested. The state's attorney asked the court to apply that maximum and then use discretion to reduce the total to USD 35 billion to USD 40 billion, arguing this level would be meaningful while respecting constitutional limits on excessive fines. The state also asked for pre-judgment and post-judgment interest, which would accrue during any appeal.

Meta's Defense and the Risks

Meta Platforms (NASDAQ:META) called the request astronomical and argued the state failed to prove any resident was actually misled. It asked for a cap of USD 3.45 billion, about one tenth of the high end of the state's request, simple arithmetic. Both sides are likely to appeal, and the cases may take years. The shares edged up 0.1 percent premarket on October 2. The company has also faced other privacy and teen safety cases, and reports suggest settlement talks with state attorneys general in a separate matter.

Where Things Stand

A penalty of USD 35 billion to USD 40 billion is a request, not a ruling, and the judge's range between USD 3.45 billion and USD 40 billion is wide. Meta Platforms (NASDAQ:META) faces a legal overhang but the market reaction so far has been muted. A ruling is expected later this month, and appeals could reduce or delay payment. Investors should watch the ruling date and any change in the state's interest request.