Key Highlights

  • Goolsbee said the fact that the Fed has been 5-1/2 years above its inflation target is playing with fire.
  • He said the Fed needs evidence that inflation is coming back down before getting comfortable.
  • He called for revisiting the logic of looking through supply shocks such as oil price spikes.
  • His stance contrasted with John Williams, who said there was no need for urgency after the September hike.

The Chicago Fed president warned on Tuesday that the sheer length of the inflation overshoot has become a risk in itself, and called for evidence that prices are cooling.

Goolsbee does not mince words

Austan Goolsbee did not mince words. On a day when bond yields hit multi-decade highs and a fellow policymaker counseled patience, the president of the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago warned that the Fed cannot afford to get comfortable with inflation.

"The fact we have been 5-1/2 years above inflation target is playing with fire," Goolsbee said.

Why duration matters

Goolsbee's point is about time. Central bankers worry that the longer inflation stays above target, the more households and businesses start to expect it to continue. Workers push for bigger raises, companies raise prices more readily, and those expectations can become self-fulfilling. Keeping expectations anchored is one of the Fed's most important jobs.

Five and a half years is a long stretch by any measure, stretching back to the post-pandemic price surge. In Goolsbee's telling, that track record makes the current moment more dangerous, not less.

He set out a clear condition for comfort: "we have to get evidence that inflation is coming back down," he said.

Rethinking supply shocks

Goolsbee also questioned a long-standing Fed habit. "Need to revisit the logic of looking through supply shocks," he said.

Central banks have often chosen to ignore, or "look through," price spikes caused by temporary supply disruptions, such as a jump in oil prices, on the theory that they fade on their own. That question is highly relevant now: the war involving Iran, in its seventh month, has kept energy prices elevated, with Brent crude on track for a steep gain in September even after settling down $2.69 at $102.59 on Tuesday.

Deficits and AI in the mix

Goolsbee flagged other sources of pressure. "Massive deficits are a form of stimulus, can overheat economy," he said. He also warned that "expectation of productivity gains from AI in the future creates a high danger of overheating now."

Goolsbee will be a voting member of the Federal Open Market Committee in 2027, though as a regional Fed president he takes part in every policy discussion now.

A contrast with Williams

His remarks stood in contrast to those of New York Fed President John Williams, who said, "With the policy action we took at our September meeting, there is no need for urgency." After Williams spoke, odds of an October rate hike fell to roughly a coin flip, according to market reports. Fed Governor Michael Barr sided more with the hawks, saying further policy adjustments are likely needed.

The Fed raised rates at its September meeting, and bond investors are clearly bracing for more. The 30-year Treasury yield hit its highest level since 2002, and the 10-year reached its highest in roughly two decades. The S&P 500 slipped 12.85 points to 7,670.84, and the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 131.59 points to 51,349.92.

The Evidence Goolsbee Wants: PCE, GDP and Payrolls

The evidence Goolsbee wants begins arriving on Wednesday, September 30, with August PCE inflation data, the Fed's preferred inflation gauge, and the third GDP estimate at 8:30 a.m. ET. The September jobs report follows Friday, October 2, and the Fed meets October 27 and 28.