Key Highlights

● Gap reported Earnings of $0.82 a share against $0.78 expected.

● Net sales were $4.00 billion against $4.02 billion expected.

● Full-year earnings guidance is $2.29 to $2.34 a share.

● The company credited better merchandise margins and Old Navy momentum.

Gap Inc. (NYSE:GAP) topped third-quarter profit estimates after the close on Thursday, November 19, helped by better merchandise margins and momentum at Old Navy and its namesake brand, and its shares climbed in after-hours trading despite a slight miss on sales.

Profit ahead, sales just short

Gap reported third-quarter earnings of $0.82 a share, ahead of the $0.78 consensus. Net sales came to $4.00 billion, a touch below the $4.02 billion analysts expected but up modestly from a year earlier.

The quality of the beat mattered. The company credited better merchandise margins. It also pointed to momentum at Old Navy and the Gap brand.

A mixed outlook

The forward guidance was less tidy. Gap guided full-year earnings to $2.29 to $2.34 a share, a range whose top end sits just below the $2.35 consensus. The company cut its full-year sales outlook to roughly flat. Gap also named a new chief executive for its Athleta brand.

Investors chose to focus on profitability, setting aside the slight sales miss and the trimmed sales outlook for now. The shares rose after hours. That reaction suggests the market valued evidence of healthier margins and Brand momentum more than the softer top line.

Standing out in a rough retail week

The response stood in contrast to much of what happened in retail on Thursday. Williams-Sonoma (NYSE:WSM) plunged to the bottom of the S&P 500 after a near-miss on sales and a warning about higher diesel costs. Ross Stores (NASDAQ:ROST) fell after hours when its holiday-quarter earnings guide came in below consensus. Walmart (NASDAQ:WMT) slipped even after beating estimates and raising its forecast.

Consumer discretionary was the worst-performing sector during the regular session, and the broader market was hit hard. The S&P 500 dropped 147.80 points to 7,175.83, its sixth straight loss. The Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 1,101.11 points to 49,097.06, closing below 50,000 at its lowest level since May 4, and small caps suffered too.

Gap is generally viewed as part of the mid-cap universe rather than a large cap. The S&P MidCap 400 fell sharply in line with the broad market during the regular session.

The turnaround story

A quarter in which margins improved and Old Navy and Gap showed momentum gives investors something to point to, even as the flat sales outlook shows the company is not yet growing quickly.

The appointment of a new leader at Athleta puts attention on that brand as well. Athleta, which focuses on women's activewear, competes in a crowded category; shares of a major athleisure rival, fell heavily on Thursday.

What to watch

The holiday season will be the next big test for the retailer and its brands. Investors will watch whether Old Navy and Gap can keep their momentum through Black Friday and December, and whether merchandise margins hold up if competitors discount more aggressively to clear inventory. The new Athleta leadership's plans will draw attention, as will any update to the roughly flat sales outlook and any change in the full-year earnings range relative to the $2.35 consensus. Broader factors, including the Federal Reserve's December 8–9 meeting and November Inflation data due on December 10, will shape how much consumers feel able to spend.