Key Highlights

● Net income and EPS fell despite higher revenue

● Added Colstrip ownership costs are not yet covered in rates

● Montana vote on the Black Hills Merger is the final approval

● Data center plans remain short of binding contracts

NorthWestern Energy Group, Inc. (NASDAQ:NWE), among the Northern Plains Utility stocks, said that Net Income and Diluted Earnings per Share for the third quarter fell from a year earlier on both a GAAP and an adjusted basis, even as Revenue rose. The company affirmed its full-year non-GAAP earnings guidance on a standalone basis while waiting for Montana regulators to rule on its all-stock merger with Black Hills Corp. (NYSE:BKH).

Chief Executive Brian Bird said the Colstrip costs have created a temporary earnings headwind, a description that addresses the central feature of the quarter. On the first day of this year, NorthWestern took on additional ownership in the Colstrip coal plant in Montana, at no purchase price. The associated operating costs are not yet in Montana base rates, and the power sold from those interests did not cover them in the quarter.

The timing gives the release more weight than an ordinary earnings report. The Montana Public Service Commission is scheduled to vote on the merger, according to market data. It is the final regulatory approval the companies are seeking. Once the merger closes, NorthWestern's standalone guidance and outlook would no longer apply, a point the company makes explicitly.

Inside the Quarter's Margin and Expense Lines

Revenue grew in both the electric and Natural Gas businesses from the third quarter of last year. Utility margin, which the company uses to measure revenue net of energy Supply costs, also expanded, and electric volumes benefited from favorable weather and customer growth in all of the company's jurisdictions. Gas volumes benefited from favorable weather and growth in Montana, partly offset by unfavorable weather in South Dakota and Nebraska.

The pressure appeared further down the income statement. Gross margin fell, mainly because of negative margin from the added Colstrip interests and higher depreciation. Operating expenses excluding fuel increased markedly, with electric generation maintenance the largest change. Both the former Puget Sound Energy interests and the former Avista (NYSE:AVA) interests added to maintenance expense. Merger-related costs came in lower than a year earlier, providing a partial offset.

Operating income declined accordingly. Interest expense increased because of higher borrowings and rates, partly offset by higher Capitalization of funds used during construction. Other income fell, mainly because of a lower value on deferred shares held in trust for deferred compensation. Income tax expense also fell, with the effective rate lower than a year earlier.

In its bridge to adjusted earnings, the company adds back merger-related costs and the Avista Colstrip interests, and it makes a small deduction for favorable weather. Adjusted earnings per share still declined, because a year earlier the company had added back larger amounts for unfavorable weather and for merger costs. The treatment of the Avista interests as an adjustment is notable, because it reflects management's view that those costs are not part of normalized operations while rate recovery is pending. Results for the year to date followed the same direction, with higher revenue and lower net income and earnings per share.

How the Colstrip Deals Work and Why They Hurt Now

NorthWestern's Colstrip position comes from a pair of transactions completed at the start of the year. The Puget interests raised the company's stake, and they sit in a Subsidiary regulated by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. The Avista interests further increased ownership, and the slide deck released with the results shows the combined additional capacity. Each Acquisition carried no purchase price, but each brought a recurring annual operating cost.

The Puget and Avista interests differ in their economics. The Puget interests are covered by a sales contract running through late next year, which the company expects to largely offset the added costs, and the federal regulator approved cost-based and contract rates in February, retroactive to the start of the year. The Avista interests rely on an interim Tariff Waiver approved by the Montana commission in January for designated sales contracts. In both the quarter and the year to date, the company says, power prices were insufficient to cover those operating costs.

The Avista side of the transaction has been in the works for years. When the agreement was signed, According to market data, the deal carried no cost to NorthWestern and state officials regarded the units' continued operation as important for grid reliability. It also reported that Avista needed an exit because of laws in other states that bar the purchase of coal-fired electricity. Bird said recently that the decision helps ensure reliable energy for customers and supports economic development in Montana.

Legal questions remain open on the Puget portion. A pair of Montana commissioners, acting individually, sought rehearing of the federal approval, which was denied by operation of law, and they appealed to the Ninth Circuit in June. The court has held the case in abeyance until the middle of December. The commission's merger discussion has also touched this asset: Commissioner Jennifer Fielder sought time to propose a condition reserving a portion of the Puget Colstrip capacity for Montana customers if that power proved the most affordable option.

The Montana Decision Is the Last Remaining Hurdle

The merger agreement was signed in August of last year, creating what would be called Bright Horizon Energy Corporation. The release lists the completed steps: Shareholder approval and expiration of the antitrust Waiting Period in April, approvals from the federal regulator and the Nebraska commission in May, and approval from the South Dakota commission in June. A settlement with key intervenors in Montana, reached in April, remains subject to the state commission's approval.

Black Hills' own third-quarter release, also states that closing depends on a satisfactory final approval from Montana and that the company is awaiting that decision. Both companies continue to expect closing by the end of the year, subject to closing conditions.

According to market data, commissioners voted in late October to postpone their decision to a later meeting, with the statutory deadline falling shortly after. Fielder, Jeff Welborn and Randy Pinocci supported the delay, and Annie Bukacek and Kirk Bushman opposed it. Commission staff backed approval, citing support from the Montana Consumer Counsel, and the deal includes ring-fencing measures that bar the use of the utility's Assets to secure affiliates' Debt and prohibit commingling funds with an affiliate.

Opposition has been persistent. A long line of members of the public urged the commission to reject the deal at the late-October meeting, citing plans to serve data centers and possible increases in residential costs, and opposing groups, including the Montana Farmers Union, continued to resist it. Several speakers recalled the deregulation of Montana Power Company in the late twentieth century, when rates rose and pensions disappeared.

The Arguments Heard at the Hearing

The May hearing, as covered by market data, framed the opposing sides of the argument. Sarah Norcott, a lawyer for NorthWestern, said the company's Montana utility operations will remain exactly where they are today. Wiley Barker, a lawyer for Black Hills, said the transaction was a true merger of equals rather than an acquisition. The utilities argued that the combined company would handle market Volatility better and have easier access to capital for infrastructure.

Monica Tranel, a lawyer for the Montana Farmers Union and an allied group, called the deal a betrayal of Montanans. Opponents argued that the transaction mainly benefits executives, bankers and shareholders, cited transaction fees and the higher shareholder returns, and noted that Black Hills would hold the majority of the Parent Company and of its board seats. Critics also said a customer Credit in the proposal amounted to a small sum per household, and raised concerns about Job cuts tied to expected labor savings.

NorthWestern's investor materials make the case in financial terms. The company says the merger would increase scale, raise the combined company's target earnings growth above NorthWestern's standalone target, roughly double each company's rate base, and diversify the Business across contiguous jurisdictions. The combined company would operate in Montana, South Dakota, Arkansas, Colorado, Iowa, Kansas, Nebraska and Wyoming.

Data Center Plans Remain Short of Binding Contracts

Large-load Demand underpins much of the debate. NorthWestern reported development agreements with Atlas Power Holdings and Quantica Infrastructure for Montana data centers, and said a third agreement with Sabey Data Centers has been terminated. Its load forecast starts in late next year and envisions substantial growth by the end of the decade. The company says it is working to execute electric service agreements, while resources and regulatory mechanisms remain under evaluation.

The investor presentation offers a sober reading of that progress. A larger queue of Montana projects is at the request stage, with only those Atlas and Quantica projects at the development-agreement stage, and none has yet reached an energy service agreement or construction. The company expects Montana load to be served from the existing portfolio, which it describes as long on capacity beginning this year. Large customers requiring new generation would be expected to post credit support during construction.

NorthWestern filed a Large New Load tariff rule with the Montana commission in March, setting different treatment by load size, with the largest customers needing commission review of their service agreements before service begins. Discovery has begun, but no settlement or hearing dates have been set. PSC staff attorney Pam Snyder-Varns told commissioners in October that data centers are part of a separate case, in response to Pinocci's interest in having data centers help offset residential costs.

Black Hills has moved further on this front elsewhere. Its release recently reported definitive agreements signed at the end of September to serve a planned Google (NASDAQ:GOOGL) Data Center in Cheyenne, Wyoming, which it described as an upside to its capital plan. That development appears in NorthWestern's prospective partner's accounts rather than in NorthWestern's own, but it illustrates part of the scale argument the companies have presented for the combination.

South Dakota Generation and the Wider Capital Program

Beyond Montana, the company's largest new project is Hub City Energy Park, a natural gas plant in Aberdeen, South Dakota, submitted to the Southwest Power Pool last autumn under its expedited resource adequacy study program. The plant is targeted for the end of the decade, and turbine milestone payments have already been recorded. The company says the need stems from the regional operator's higher planning reserve margin requirements.

A rider filing made in South Dakota in June covers the Aberdeen Generating Station, certain nuclear study costs and Hub City, and is pending before the South Dakota commission. South Dakota has also changed its wildfire Liability framework: legislation signed in March bars strict liability claims for utility-caused wildfire damages and sets a statutory standard of care. NorthWestern filed and published a wildfire mitigation plan in July.

The company affirmed its record capital plan for the current year and for the multi-year period through the end of the decade, supporting its stated rate base growth target. Funding comes from cash flows, credit facilities, debt and future rate increases, with Equity issuance expected to begin next year for the South Dakota generation. Revolving credit capacity was increased in August, and total net Liquidity at the end of September was higher than a year earlier. On transmission, the company holds nonbinding arrangements with Grid United, including the North Plains Connector project.

Montana Rates Remain Unsettled

Montana's regulatory matters extend beyond the merger. Last December, the commission approved a partial electric settlement in the company's rate review, temporarily suspended the cost-sharing mechanism for power costs and disallowed part of the capital costs for the Yellowstone County Generating Station, which produced a non-cash charge in the fourth quarter of last year. NorthWestern asked the commission in January to reconsider, seeking review of its prudence conclusions and a different effective date for the suspension.

The company now expects the suspension of the mechanism to be resolved in the first half of next year. Cost sharing has been suspended on an interim basis since the beginning of February, and that suspension is a Factor in the year-over-year comparison of supply costs. The company's guidance assumptions explicitly include approval of the tariff waiver and sufficient power prices to recover Colstrip costs. Since power prices did not cover those costs in the third quarter, that assumption merits attention in the fourth-quarter report if the standalone company still exists to issue one.

Dividend Dates Shift as the Merger Clock Runs

One practical signal of the approaching decision is the dividend. NorthWestern's board declared its regular quarterly dividend, and it moved up the payment and record dates from the original schedule because of the merger's dividend coordination provisions. Black Hills declared its own quarterly dividend, with the same payment and record dates, according to its release recently.

If the merger closes before the mid-November record date, each NorthWestern share would convert to a fixed fraction of a Black Hills share, and eligible holders would receive the dividend Black Hills declared. NorthWestern's long-term Payout Ratio target applies only until closing. These mechanics show how the companies have aligned their calendars around the Montana decision, though the outcome of that vote and any conditions attached to it remain unknown.

NorthWestern serves electric and natural gas customers in Montana, South Dakota, Nebraska and Yellowstone National Park. With the Montana commission scheduled to take up the merger and its deadline shortly after, the company's next significant disclosure may concern the deal rather than the quarter's Colstrip costs, and the terms of any commission order will shape how the combined company approaches both.