Key Highlights

● Fiscal-year EPS rose; adjusted EPS climbed at a high single-digit pace

● Fourth-quarter reported EPS fell on Ohio and separation costs

● Fiscal 2027 adjusted guidance sits below the year just ended

● Seneca spin-off targeted for the second half of 2027

National Fuel Gas Company (NYSE:NFG), a name that sits among gas-focused Utility stocks while still drawing a large share of its profit from Appalachian production, reported fourth-quarter and full-year results. Earnings Per Share rose for the fiscal year that ended in September on both a reported and an adjusted basis, and adjusted earnings per share climbed at a high single-digit pace. The same release set adjusted earnings guidance for the new fiscal year at a level below the year just finished.

The report arrives at an unusual moment for the Williamsville, New York, company. Its purchase of the Ohio gas utility formerly owned by CenterPoint Energy (NYSE:CNP) closed on the first day of October, once the reporting period had ended. Weeks later, the board approved a plan to spin off the Integrated Upstream and Gathering business, known as IUG, into a separate publicly traded company. The numbers published therefore describe a Business that has already begun to change shape.

President and Chief Executive David P. Bauer opened his statement by calling the fiscal year "an excellent year for National Fuel." The release gave a detailed account of each segment, and the picture that emerges is uneven: stronger full-year earnings in production and the utility, slightly softer earnings in pipelines, and a widening loss at the corporate level as deal expenses passed through.

Deal Expenses Cloud the Final Quarter

The fourth quarter looked weaker than the full year on a reported basis. Earnings and earnings per share under generally accepted accounting principles both fell from the prior-year quarter, and the company attributed the decline mainly to costs tied to the Ohio Acquisition and the planned separation. Adjusted earnings per share, which strip out those items, came in level with the same quarter a year earlier.

The Corporate and All Other category shows where those costs landed. Its reported loss for the quarter widened sharply from the prior-year period, driven by transaction and financing costs for Ohio and by separation costs. For the full year, the adjusted loss in that category also grew from the previous year.

Cash generation offered a firmer signal. Operating Cash Flow for the year was substantial, and the company reported positive free cash flow under its own definition of that measure. Bauer pointed to strong free cash flow alongside earnings growth when summarizing the year, according to the release.

Higher Prices Offset Fewer Molecules at Seneca

The upstream and gathering segment remained the largest earnings contributor. Its adjusted earnings rose from the prior-year quarter, while adjusted EBITDA was essentially flat. The company credited higher realized Natural Gas prices, lower interest expense and lower income taxes, and it said lower production partly offset those gains.

Production at Seneca Resources declined from the prior-year quarter as output from new wells failed to keep pace with natural declines in existing ones. Realized pricing moved the other way, rising by a mid-to-high single-digit rate from the prior year. That combination of more Revenue per unit on fewer units sold explains why the segment could grow earnings without growing volume.

Unit costs edged up. Total operating cost per unit of production rose from the prior-year quarter, with cash operating costs lifted mainly by Lease Operating Expense and third-party gathering charges. Depreciation, depletion and amortization per unit also increased, partly because ceiling test impairments recorded in the previous fiscal year had reduced the earlier rate, which made the prior-year comparison unusually low. Gathering operating and maintenance cost per unit increased modestly as well.

Reserves moved in a favorable direction. Proved Reserves at the end of September stood above the prior-year level, and Seneca replaced well over its fiscal-year production. Proved developed reserves accounted for a substantial majority of the total. The release also described a discretionary land acquisition program in Tioga County that is adding acreage. Across the full year, adjusted segment earnings climbed from the prior year.

Pipelines Slip While New Projects Enter Service

Pipeline and Storage earnings dipped modestly in the quarter, and adjusted EBITDA for the segment declined slightly. Revenues rose on new long-term contracts, but higher operating and maintenance costs from fuel and materials, together with higher Depreciation on a larger base of plant in service, more than absorbed that increase. Full-year adjusted earnings also finished a little below the prior year.

The more forward-looking detail lies outside the quarter. The Tioga Pathway and Shippingport Lateral projects both entered service at the start of November, which means neither contributed to the reported period. The company also acquired Honeoye Storage Corporation at the end of October. An investor presentation filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission described that deal as a small purchase that adds firm storage capacity, all of it subscribed.

A rate proceeding remains open on the interstate side. National Fuel Gas Supply Corporation has a rate case pending, and the company expects a resolution by the end of the calendar year. When the separation plan was announced in October, trade publication Market commentary noted the company's view that growing gas demand, including from data centers and power generation, is increasing the need for new pipeline and storage infrastructure in its footprint.

The Utility Narrows Its Loss on Regulatory Support

The Utility segment posted a loss for the quarter, though smaller than the loss a year earlier, and its adjusted EBITDA improved. Customer Margin increased on higher usage, the second year of a joint settlement in New York and revenue from a Pennsylvania infrastructure surcharge. Those gains were partly offset by higher operating and maintenance costs, reflecting fuel costs and an unfavorable comparison in uncollectible expense. Adjusted earnings for the full year rose from the prior year.

Regulators in both of the company's established states delivered outcomes during the period. In New York, a System Modernization Tracker won approval, and in Pennsylvania the company obtained approval of a Base Rate increase. Those outcomes add to the regulatory record of a business set to become a larger share of the enterprise.

Affordability sits close to that discussion. Speaking when the split was announced, Chief Financial Officer Tim Silverstein told market data that the company has long had the lowest delivery rates in each state across its New York and Pennsylvania territories, and said that "maintaining affordable rates is a win-win." He added that the company expects to bring the same focus to Ohio.

What Ohio Adds to the Regulated Base

The Ohio purchase is the event that changes the scale of the utility. The acquired business, Vectren Energy Delivery of Ohio, operates a large network of transmission and distribution pipelines and serves a large base of metered customers in West Central Ohio, according to market data. The deal needed federal and state approvals, including review by the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio. National Fuel says the transaction roughly doubles its Utility rate base.

For the counterparty, the sale fits a different strategy. Market commentary described it as a step in CenterPoint's effort to concentrate Investment on core regulated operations, with proceeds helping to fund a long-range Capital plan for electric and gas infrastructure in Texas, Indiana and Minnesota. The article also noted a broader pattern of regulated utilities reshuffling portfolios toward jurisdictions with stronger expected investment and more predictable returns.

Financing has left a marker on the balance sheet. The November investor presentation listed a common Equity issuance, a sizable amount of new long-term Debt and a further note issued to the seller that falls due at the end of September next year. The company reported investment-grade ratings from S&P, Moody's and Fitch, although the S&P and Moody's grades sit at the lowest investment-grade rung, and it has a committed Credit Facility in place. How the maturing note is ultimately addressed appears to be a practical question for the coming year, particularly with a corporate separation running in parallel.

Inside the Seneca Separation Plan

The separation announced in mid-October would create an independent Appalachian producer expected to take the Seneca Resources name and trade on the New York Stock Exchange. National Fuel plans a tax-free pro rata distribution of at least a large majority stake in IUG to its shareholders. It may retain a minority position, which it plans to dispose of in a tax-efficient way. The company continues to expect completion in the second half of next calendar year.

Conditions remain. The presentation lists final board approval, the effectiveness of a registration statement with the Securities and Exchange Commission, completed financing arrangements and favorable tax treatment. According to market data, the split also needs federal regulatory approval. Market data named Goldman Sachs (NYSE:GS) as financial adviser, Veriten as independent strategic adviser and Skadden as legal counsel.

The stated rationale centers on capital allocation. In its announcement, the company said separation would give each business more flexibility on spending and Shareholder returns, with its own leadership, Balance Sheet and capital structure, and with an investor base better matched to its profile. Management argued that the integrated model had supplied the cash flow and financial capacity behind major acquisitions, and that the Ohio closing left each business scaled enough to stand alone. Market commentary summarized Bauer's point as the closing having left each business "as a scaled platform."

Leadership has been mapped out. Bauer and Treasurer and Chief Financial Officer Timothy J. Silverstein stay in their posts at National Fuel, while Justin Loweth, president of Seneca Resources and NFG Midstream, is expected to become chief executive of the new company. Loweth described the upstream business to market data as "a differentiated investment opportunity." The company's announcement credited IUG with a meaningful improvement in capital efficiency since development shifted to its Eastern Development Area, along with an extensive inventory of low-breakeven drilling locations.

Reading the Lower Guidance Range

Adjusted earnings per share guidance for the new fiscal year falls below the result just reported, and the range rests on explicit Commodity assumptions. The company based it on a NYMEX natural gas price close to the current forward curve, with a lower assumed price for Appalachian spot sales. Guidance includes IUG for the entire year because that business stays consolidated until the separation is finished.

A disclosed sensitivity table shows how much of the outlook depends on price. The range moves lower at a weaker NYMEX assumption and higher at stronger assumptions, and at the top of the disclosed price scale the implied range approaches, though does not reach, the adjusted result of the year just ended. The table makes clear that the upstream business still shapes the consolidated earnings picture, even as the corporate story tilts toward regulation.

Production guidance incorporates estimated price-related Marketing curtailments in October, a sign that price conditions are already shaping planned volumes early in the fiscal year. The release did not provide a guidance figure on a reported basis, explaining that it cannot reasonably estimate certain unrealized investment gains or losses.

Capital spending plans cover each operating business. IUG accounts for the largest share, and discretionary land spending is budgeted separately on top of it. The Utility budget is the next largest, and Pipeline and Storage has the smallest allocation. The company also published expected ranges for Pipeline and Storage revenue, Utility Operating Income and per-unit upstream costs, giving analysts a detailed framework for testing the outlook during the year.

The Regulated Company Left Behind

After the spin-off, National Fuel would be a fully rate-regulated natural gas company with a sizable rate base, utilities serving customers across Ohio, New York and Pennsylvania, and Federal Energy Regulatory Commission-regulated pipeline and storage Assets under contract. Bauer told market data that those states have "constructive regulatory frameworks that support ongoing investments."

The company's own framing of that future business includes investment-grade credit metrics, a capital return policy similar to those of utility peers and no need to raise new equity on current plans over its multi-year planning horizon. The November presentation estimates long-term rate base growth at a mid-to-high single-digit pace. Those are management projections rather than outcomes, and they depend on the regulatory decisions and financing conditions the company itself lists as uncertain.

The shareholder return record adds continuity to the transition. The board raised the Dividend again this year, extending a run of annual increases of more than half a century, and Bauer noted that dividends have been paid for well over a century.

Risks the Company Puts on Record

The forward-looking section of the release lists the factors that could cause results to differ materially. Separation execution comes prominently, covering completion of the spin-off, approvals, intended capital structures and credit ratings, and tax treatment. Commodity exposure is another group, including natural gas prices, basis differentials and possible full cost ceiling impairments, the same kind of charge that affected the prior fiscal year.

Regulatory and policy items include rate case outcomes, environmental and climate rules and pressure to reduce natural gas use. Operational risks range from drilling and production uncertainty and reserve estimates to equipment constraints, weather and third-party outages. Financial items include access to credit, interest rates and possible rating downgrades. The company also lists cybersecurity, labor negotiations, pension and benefit costs, insurance costs, tariffs and activist shareholder campaigns.

Taken together, the report leaves several items open for the months ahead: the Supply Corporation rate case resolution, the first results that include Ohio, the handling of the seller note and the registration filing for the planned spin-off. Each will show how closely the transition follows the plan management described recently, and how much of the near-term earnings story continues to turn on the price of natural gas.